Members: johnnymag >> Critiques Written

Register

Critiques: Critiques Written | Critiques Received | Comments
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  >

PhotoCritique [Translate]

johnnymag Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 95 W: 18 N: 465] (2357) [2009-01-08 1:25] [+]

Hi Bev,

Happy New Year and many congrats at reaching 10k, quite an achievement.......well done!! Great pic, wonderful effect...

All the best,

John

johnnymag Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 95 W: 18 N: 465] (2357) [2008-10-16 2:48]

Hi Kristina,

I love this photo and the way you have presented the subject. The leaves should be falling out of your picture! Very clever, and I also like the sharp focus on the leaves in the water! Well done and a belated welcome to TL :)

Thanks for your kind comments on my train pic.

John

johnnymag Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 95 W: 18 N: 465] (2357) [2008-10-06 6:11]

Hi Arthur,

Great first image, welcome to TL....great start. I concur with the comments already left re room and the need for notes to accompany your images.

Framing the boat slightly lower in the frame could have resulted in having a nice diagonal line through the scene which I think may have enhanced the shot. Well done and TFS,

John

johnnymag Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 95 W: 18 N: 465] (2357) [2008-10-02 8:06]

Hi Magda,

Love the compo, the arms and hands frame the 'bump' well. Very good light with nice skin tones. Well done and TFS,

John

johnnymag Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 95 W: 18 N: 465] (2357) [2008-10-02 8:02]

Hi Constantin,

Great image. Love the sharpness with the waterdrops going everywhere. Good point of focus and nice exposure throughout.

I bet your granddaughter wasn't pleased by the experience!

regards,

John

johnnymag Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 95 W: 18 N: 465] (2357) [2008-10-02 7:58]

Hi Hans,

Stunning image. Great depth and detail. Extremely sharp throughout. Great compo and like you say the red canopy against the mountains is striking.

Great addition to the theme.

Thanks,

John

johnnymag Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 95 W: 18 N: 465] (2357) [2008-09-30 3:47]

Hi Igori,

Great pictorial image. I love the candid nature and the balance that you have here. Love the fact that the girls are looking in the same direction and have mirrored legs....great stuff. Don't know whether it was posed or not, dosn't matter really, except it would have been good to be able to loose the ugly drain pipe on the right, and kept the girls within the same textured bg.

Great work, well done and TFS. Congrats on your 20th post. Belated welcome to TL,

John

johnnymag Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 95 W: 18 N: 465] (2357) [2008-09-28 8:20]

Hi Magda,

Brilliant!! Love the candid nature of this, what a great idea...love the directions you have created. Well done and TFS,

John

johnnymag Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 95 W: 18 N: 465] (2357) [2008-09-25 12:29]

Hey Magda,

How are you.....Its been a while since ive seen a posting from you, thought you'd left, but great to see this image. Love the clean lines, very commercial look. Great idea and very well executed. Great colours and sharpness. I won't ask where you other leg is!! :)

TFS,

John

johnnymag Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 95 W: 18 N: 465] (2357) [2008-09-25 12:26]

Hey Kevin,

Love this image. You have created a wonderful mood here. Love the lead in lines with the fence, and the compo is excellent. The mist and the backlit ring on the horse is just superb.

Excellent contribution to the theme, well done and TFs,

John