Members: webbbill >> Critiques Written

Register

Critiques: Critiques Written | Critiques Received | Comments
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  >

PhotoCritique [Translate]

webbbill Silver Note Writer [C: 7 W: 0 N: 31] (174) [2007-03-16 8:54]

Superb composition, clarity and color. (But it DOES make me want to sneeze.)

The black frame helps accentuate the colors.

Bill

webbbill Silver Note Writer [C: 7 W: 0 N: 31] (174) [2007-03-08 8:38]

Nice location. I like the composition but the blurring you used to make the rocks stand out detracts from the photo (for me). You might have used a vignetting effect to slightly darken the perimiter of the photo while leaving the rocks bright. I think that would have created the same effect wile allowing you to leave the entire shot in focus.

TFS.

Bill

webbbill Silver Note Writer [C: 7 W: 0 N: 31] (174) [2007-03-05 8:53] [+]

Great shot. The GND would also seem to hold back the top of the foreground rock. Am I correct that you were able to bring that out with a CP in NX?

If I ever get to Scotland again, I'd like to just follow you around to some of these locations and learn from you. ;-)

Regards,

Bill

webbbill Silver Note Writer [C: 7 W: 0 N: 31] (174) [2007-03-05 8:47]

Good use of the GND filter. I have also had some success with bracketing images and using HDR filter process in CS2 but it's so much nicer and sharper done in-camera like this. Great shot.

Bill

webbbill Silver Note Writer [C: 7 W: 0 N: 31] (174) [2007-02-27 17:00] [comment]

The underexposed tree trunks and limbs really add to the feeling of this shot.

TFS

Bill

webbbill Silver Note Writer [C: 7 W: 0 N: 31] (174) [2007-02-27 15:18] [comment]

Superb photo! Clairity and detail are right on.

TFS

Bill

webbbill Silver Note Writer [C: 7 W: 0 N: 31] (174) [2007-02-27 13:37] [comment]

I'll really have to study this and will count myself an expert when I can even come close to the level of results you have achieved with this.

Bill

webbbill Silver Note Writer [C: 7 W: 0 N: 31] (174) [2007-02-27 9:18]

As a study in depth of field it is good. As an abstract image it will appeal to many people but as a Nature shot without any further explanation it leaves something to be desired in my feeling.

Thanks for sharing.

Bill

webbbill Silver Note Writer [C: 7 W: 0 N: 31] (174) [2007-02-27 9:14]

Intruiging photo. I get a sense of an Eskimo Nativity from this scene.

The stray lights in the background are a little distracting. Perhaps they are a star and an angel and I just can't make them out properly.

Thanks for sharing.

Bill

Italy
Title: lamp
lamp (2)
lionfish (116)

Great

webbbill Silver Note Writer [C: 7 W: 0 N: 31] (174) [2007-02-27 9:11]

Intruiging image. Good composition. Good DOF. I would like to see a version of it lit more from the side or the front to give more punch to the colors.

Nice shot.

Bill