DON QUIJOTE VS WINDMILLS IN THE SAHARA

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• salil (2100)
• [2005-11-26 11:26]
•  [Show CommentHide Comment]

•  
• marienne (13)
• [2005-11-26 15:33]

interesting philosophy behind the pic.
maybe you should just try to give the man and horse a good long late sunset shadow for realism...

•  
• rui (0)
• [2005-11-26 18:02]

Hi Nejat !
This is your matrix, excellent photograph and concepts concerning the life and the humanity! Continue with your work because it has much content, congratulations.
All the best,
Rui

•  
• bullybeef53 (2945)
• [2005-11-26 18:04]

I am glad you wrote a note . This photograph has a great composition . Jim

•  
• samr (3323)
• [2005-11-27 1:59]

Hi Nejat - interesting thoughts and symbolism. Great combination photo, and very artistic. The whole presentation is great. TFS, Sam

•  
• pablominto (27446)
• [2005-11-27 6:01]

Hi Nejat,
Excellent graphic effect! Good layout... will make a very appealing poster... Great colours!
Regards,
Pablo -

•  
• chrisJ (41765)
• [2005-11-27 6:20]

Hi nejat

I like the repetition of the mosque / windmills. Excellent color & graphism. Good pp work. Tfs!

•  
• cleocat (4244)
• [2005-11-27 11:11]

The colours are great. Nice composition with the mosques at the far end and the man on the horse infront. The wide open space between them creates distance and a lonliness. Great note. Is a war ever sensible?

•  
• Victor (3388)
• [2005-11-27 11:55]

Hi Nejat,
Great composition, beatiful colores and creative imagination, well done.
Regards,
Victor

•  
• fer (8073)
• [2005-11-28 5:14]

Hi Nejat,

You have a unique style...Nejat style,you make interesting compositions with yours PP works.Nice note too.
Obrigado brother,
Fernando

•      
• clix_stuff (2303)
• [2005-11-28 5:23]

Interesting thought and work over all...Thanks for sharing

•  
• fotofrancis (1336)
• [2005-11-28 17:44]
• - [workshop] [compare]

Very interesting creation... I see that since I have been away you have been re-inventing surealism... very good... there is need for it... there is far too much fact, and not enough fiction in this world... And the stranger the better I say... ;)

Now I suppose I should say something in critic of the picture... well,
Raspberry! hehehe

But realy they say that a picture tells a thousand words... then how many does a half good workshop tell... hmm I wonder... so I will do what I haven't done for SO long... do a work shop! You just try and stop me....

Now here I am revisiting this critic again... and why? Because I read your note... :)

I so enjoy the thoughts here. And wish that such windmills could only be productive and not destructive.

•  
• Photograph2u (0)
• [2005-11-29 9:36]

Hello Nejat, this is beautiful and well thought of. Great photo for great notes. Your idea is very well rendered.

Personnly, I prefer the wide perpective here than on the ws.

Great mood here and great sunset! And your knight is a great addition.

Take care, Yan :)

•  
• ed-lin (292)
• [2005-11-29 11:18]

verry nice pic beautifull colors light en dark whit a good frame good composition TFS
greets ed_lin

•  
• jcandeli (3985)
• [2005-11-29 11:56]

very cool idea. It looks very tastefully done. The composition is well balanced. nice job! JP

•  
• CTP (42)
• [2005-11-29 12:00]

Merhaba Nejat,
Harika bir photoshop calismasi olmus.
Renkler,contrast,focus,sharpness,frame ve not harika.Eline Saglik.TFS
CT

•  
• tsumeb (2122)
• [2005-11-29 21:05]

Nejat . . . Iloveyour stuff. Fun, free and artistic. This one is very dramatic and surreal. Well done!

•  
• jacojvr (4032)
• [2005-11-30 23:16]
• - [workshop] [compare] [+]

It is a beatiful picture Nejat. However, too much sand in the foreground distracts from the beautiful architecture. See the workshop I've done on it. Good capture
jaco

•  
• Televana (1018)
• [2005-12-01 4:23]

Hi Nejat, it's like a sceen from the "1001 nights" so amazing colours! Great PP work!
Gabriella

•  
• LuciG (8681)
• [2005-12-01 14:49]

IMPRESSIONANTE ET PARTICULIEREMENT INTERESSANTE COMPOSITION!
Je suis éblouie ...
Félicitations!
Luci

•  
• vsinopoulos (13115)
• [2005-12-02 1:55]

My friend a very creative and original image. All elements have been put together in a masterful way. Great work!
Very nice note!
Vassilis

•  
• recepyuksel (6542)
• [2005-12-03 5:12]

çok yaratıcı ve iyi bir çalışma
güzel bir anlatım
ilginç
tebrikler
RYuksel

•  
• sharkattack (46)
• [2005-12-03 5:48]

Ustat dokturmussun burada..................sanirim biraz daha calisirsan daha iyi olurmus gibime geldi......bilmiyorum sen ne dersin.......istersen bir ws atarim senin icin.......

•  
• magda_indigo (31243)
• [2005-12-04 7:34]

SPECIAL, thanx, (*_*)

•  
• ckradolfer (0)
• [2005-12-04 18:01]

beautiful well done super color and idea very creative.
Christine.

•  
• AnneFrance (5452)
• [2005-12-07 4:34]

great compo with strong effect, beautifull colours and PP work!

•  
• Tyanne (0)
• [2005-12-09 9:10]

nice job I like the compo and thae sunset you captured

•  
• dolphin (44)
• [2005-12-10 5:28]

uh, çok büyük felsefeler doluşmuş bu kompozisyona.olayları neredeyse özetlemişsin tek bir kareyle.devam serilerini bekleriz,düşünmeye devam edelim lütfen:-)

•  
• harpya (9371)
• [2005-12-11 16:25]

beautiful, beautiful picture
a color magnifies of
excellent graph
Great composition, beautiful style
Congratulations for the picture, I loved that

Sérgio

•  
• fmg (503)
• [2005-12-11 20:33]

A beautiful picture illustrating a perfect idea. Congratulations.

•  
• Refugee (25532)
• [2005-12-18 14:37]

Hi Nejat, very interesting experiment and notes which make it all more thought provoking. Excellent layout and lovely colouring, TFS
David

•  
• hojper (4087)
• [2005-12-19 17:24]

I am at a loss for words for once. This one really is a masterpiece. I don't care how you did it, the important thing is that you did it. And it is not often that I have that reaction on TL. Thanks.

•  
• DAM (1110)
• [2005-12-20 21:34]

Nejat, I do not what to say.... if I like the picture better or you short note. I too do not agree with religious wars, or any other wars at all. What a waste of effort, humanity and so much more good could be done. You have obviously attracted many of us to your picture as it is very attractive.

DAM

•  
• ceslou (4234)
• [2005-12-21 4:43]

nicely captured nejat and a good PP work. the idea is great !

•  
• jpdeloof (4828)
• [2005-12-21 8:46]

hello netjat
Apart from all thought philosophical I notice simply that I have a beautiful photograph in front of me. As all photographs people interpret them according to their thoughts of the day. Very beautiful work.
jp

•  
• jrj (724)
• [2005-12-22 7:11]

Good work with the very adventure setting. Interesting and well made presentation.

•  
• tanbinh (3156)
• [2005-12-23 3:56]

fantastique composition!!
image faite avec beaucoup d'imagination!
bravo! bravo!
bye....aldo.

•  
• technogran (5525)
• [2005-12-26 23:37]

A very well thought out composition representing your thoughts and notes. The colouring is beautiful and the shapes of the minarets silhouetted against the sky repeatedly are really nice. I like the horseman at the bottom right to add something to the blank space. Very well done.

•  
• letr (6780)
• [2005-12-27 9:27]

Like the note here nejat, i agree with you , nice illustration to go with it , it serves the purpose..

•  
• jrendeiro (2315)
• [2006-01-05 10:17]

Hi Nejat,
You have a interesting ideia with a beuatifull result.
Very creative.!!!
José

•  
• persimon (2406)
• [2006-01-13 15:16]

This is a stunning shot. I love the colors, and the composition is amazing. Your note is interesting too.

•  
• woodyew (0)
• [2006-01-14 13:59]

Hi Nejat, Love this one. This compo has a lot going for it. It tells a story and the colours are magical. TFS, Paul.

•  
• mikoyen (5263)
• [2006-01-21 8:48]

A very nice shot Nejat, very good composition with the mosques, and the man with the horse in the front, it gives a nice effect to the picture. Lovely colors.
Best regards
Guy

•  
• maxloxton (2782)
• [2006-01-21 23:50]

It is a dream composition and photo. Very nicely done with a touch of reality and imagination in it. You have rightly said that your photos are doucmentaries.

Regards

•  
• linus (10735)
• [2006-01-22 10:42]

Hi Nejat,
This is a very creative photo. I like your idea behind this beautiful image and the note. Very good.
Sunil

•  
• surfacing (0)
• [2006-01-22 14:21]

Hi Nejat,
this is truely fantastic idea. And wonderful execution. Your interesting note makes very good complement to this picture. tfs

Marek

•  
• marmottelolo (1009)
• [2006-02-13 11:03]

tres joli coucher de soleil nejat
le cacalier rajouté c'est une bonne idée.
laurent

•      
• EOSF1 (19716)
• [2006-03-10 11:13]

A good post processed picture, good idea and good note. Thanks.

Mario

•  
• Rita (492)
• [2006-03-28 14:48]

Beautiful... The silhouettes give the touch of master to the photo. Colors and composition to deserve more of the one than 2 points

•  
• napdsp (622)
• [2006-04-09 22:06]

Powerful statement. I love the blazing colors and crisp silhouette of mosques. The sun position is wonderful. TFS.

•  
• orkhan (3541)
• [2006-07-12 5:58]

I like the idea, and it's a great job !

•  
• berek (330)
• [2006-09-26 1:15]

Merhaba Nejat bey,
süper bir çalışma renkler ve kadraj çok hoş elelrinize kollarınıza sağlık.
selamlar
Burak

•  
• clic (4714)
• [2006-10-06 15:13]

Bonjour l'Artiste!!
Quite an eye-catching creation because of warm tones and spectacular repetition of exotic architectural silhouettes.
I hope your thoughtful note will inspire many warring parties!!!!!!
Au revoir.
Robert

•  
• abramhowitz (796)
• [2006-10-23 19:26]

Hello,i like this picture,i think colours are soft and warm.
Exellent work.
Regards,Patricia.

•  
• ayniLL (786)
• [2007-10-04 12:03]

bu sitenin puanlaması digerlerine göre biraz kıt
ama siz tavan yapmışsınız fotografınızla...
güzel olan heryerde hakettiğini buluyor demek ki:)
selamlar

•  
• suhailah (287)
• [2008-04-19 12:50]

nice work! ;)
veryy creative!
love the colors here, and really like hte informative note that goes with the photo =)
well done! =)