Where We Had Never Gone

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• Luciano75 (0)
• [2006-10-09 13:55]
• [+]

hello Aleksandar

Honestly...i like more the original...if you could do to the original what you did to the final version about the white spot on walker.In this final version looks better.On the original,i like the tones on the windows(up - left side),in this one,they dissapear.Hope i helped you.Good luck at the contest!

Best wishes,
Lucian

•  
• hester (9994)
• [2006-10-09 14:35]
• [+]

Excellent PP work it is really striking. Nice composition as well. No suggestions I like it as it is. I think if you do much more then you run the risk of ruining it. Good luck

•  
• farshid (465)
• [2006-10-09 19:41]
• [+]

amazing shot Aleksandar
i like it alot
it's so dreamy and mystic.....so fantasy
...it looks like paintings

well done
i like the PP
the color tint and tone are amazing

regards
fafa

•  
• appalcarp (4188)
• [2006-10-09 20:00]
• [+]

Well done, Aleksandar. This is a great compo. The only suggestion I have is to have the man standing straight on the far left side and make the building there with the man standing alongside perpendicular. (Use your 'rotation' in the photoshop software). With this like it is, unless you are trying for that effect, he looks a little 'drunk.' Hope you win!

•  
• lion (5814)
• [2006-10-10 7:25]
• [+]

Super ti je ova slika.
Josu si odlicno uklopio. Sigurno si duuuuugo obradjivao.
U bre ti u poslednje vreme samo stancujes....imas li ti zivot??
Nebo ti je exstra...
Pozzz
E da treba mi morovind...

•  
• Ilir (5119)
• [2006-10-10 18:55]
• [+]

The power of suggestion. You mentioned whether someone dislike something here and that set my mind on finding mistakes or smthng ...

Well, if I MUST point out something that I might find not entirely functional, well, the only thing would be the frame. The coloring, tones and moods of the scenere are dark enough, so the frame sets its over-the-top, as there is nothing lacking in the shot that can be replaced or underlined stronger through a big-fat-black frame.

Very inteligent combination of modern-outfitted young pedestrian, totally on the rock side, contrasting against the ruins and baroque-dark sky. I like that you kept a dark aura around the roofs, which can be either interpreted as dark sky or as smoke.

About window coloring. You decided to leave the bottom down one in red, which is in eye-line with the pedestrian, hence the eye shifts between the two. Maybe, as a w/s option you paint red the top one, as that would be in counter-ballance with the dramatic clouds?

Vidis, ti veoma dobro znas meru u kojoj vredi koristiti PS intervencije. Mada u velikoj meri obradjene, tvoji radovi ipak ne deluju vestacki ili usiljeno. Nekako ... potsecaju me na Moby muziku - old blues in new tunes.

A.

•  
• MirellaHuisman (539)
• [2006-10-11 4:51]

I have deep respect! Why not in sepia? That looks old.

•  
• nascimentoian (48)
• [2006-10-22 6:54]

uow...

it's very vert nice shot!!!

It's original...

thanks for shot