On the air

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• ciore (2305)
• [2005-10-18 4:25]
• [+]

Carmela!
what a wonderful Point of view
and
composition of old buildings
becomes more great !
love contrasts and shadows on the walls!
Love it..
TFS ;D

Viktorija
p.s.
i agree about beautiful coloures, but b&w more stronger version this time:D
regards

•  
• ceslou (4234)
• [2005-10-18 4:34]

very good photo, carmela. very deep contrast and wonderful point of view.

•  
• jkneze2 (136)
• [2005-10-18 4:37]
• [2]

Very, very, very good! A nice balance between different textures(blanket and stone), great upward POV and an excellent shadow behind the blanket. Plus I like the B&W more then the original. Gives a feeling of decay and poverty, really good.

•  
• paul_bk (0)
• [2005-10-18 4:41]
• [+]

I think the two pictures have very different mood... the coloured is a sort of magic sunny place, this seems a house in the black forrest of fairy tales....
between two good images I preffer this....
Paolo

•  
• ropetko (0)
• [2005-10-18 4:59]

Hi Carma!
You know me, I like the color version because texture and colors of the carpet blends very well with the background, almost like some frame. Still, this version ewokes different mood, a bit ancient but very "afternoon like". Excellent shot! POV is well chosen and those vertical lines creates great composition.
Well done, congratulations!

Pozdrav,
Petko

•  
• alenist (0)
• [2005-10-18 5:11]

Very interesting image, thanks to the original POV and the dramatic atmosphere created by the BW conversion. Definitely bette rthan the colour version

•  
• mtylek (2063)
• [2005-10-18 5:27]

great bw and perspective. i love the contrast :)
great job. regard, ewa

•  
• SylFondacci (14125)
• [2005-10-18 5:54]

Hi dear !
Speedy is late ... :)
I love the pov you chose and the composition creating a very dramatic atmosphere, in a village. One can imagine a story behind these windows, some secrets. I feel like in Corsica, in some moutain villages.
Great work !
Sylvie
ps : I like both versions. The colour one is great too with warm tones. So 2 points for the B&W and 2 points for the colour one ... ;))

•  
• jubilot (332)
• [2005-10-18 8:32]

hi! great shot!
the picture has a lot of power. i like the tones and contrast! regards

•  
• jcandeli (3985)
• [2005-10-18 8:46]

beautiful b&w! I love the POV and composition. Great lighting and patterns as well. Perfect. JP

•  
• chiquito (3416)
• [2005-10-18 9:14]

Sibenik is a very beautiful little town... I was going there with a ferry from Brac!
Nice shot Carmela, I like the B&W and the angle!! Both aspect makes it strong!
cheers
ToM

•  
• jpdeloof (4828)
• [2005-10-18 9:15]
• [+]

Bonjours Charmes, entre les deux je n'hésite pas , je choisis celle en couleur ouù l'on ressent un peu de paix, un endroit calme. La B&W est dure, tranchante comme un couteau. Je trouve deux personnes différentes dans ces deux photos.
Celle dans le WS est meilleure pour son atmosphère ... La B&W c'est un peu de désastre.


good day Charms, between the two I do not hesitate, I choose that color where one feels a little peace, a calm place. The B&W is hard, sharp like a knife. I find two people different in these two photographs. That in the WS is better for its atmosphere... The B&W it is a little disaster.
amitiés
jp

•  
• balkermay (2995)
• [2005-10-18 9:39]

Hello Carmela... The wide angle creates impressive details in your composition; strong shadows make composition dramatic... Excellent...

Can

•  
• edie (0)
• [2005-10-18 13:35]

Impressive pov Carmela and pleasant old build,it tells so much human life.I preffer the b&W version.
Brava
Edie

•  
• Werewolf (26142)
• [2005-10-20 0:06]
• [+]

That's beautifull Carmela! Wat a great catch! I like how it's nice and showing well the daily life details! It's full of great texture!

•  
• Yogi (237)
• [2005-10-21 16:11]

Both versions are great on its own way! Fantastic angle BTW!

Lijep pozdrav,
Marin

•  
• stecotdon (4883)
• [2005-11-01 12:33]

Wow!! This is an amazing image. full of differnt textures, excellent tones and great POV. Very nice indeed.

Good job Carmela!!!!!

Take care, Stefania :))

•  
• Ejla (2488)
• [2006-02-12 4:29]
• [+]

jednog dana napravit ću temu pod nazivom "Laundry", a ova će biti među prvima!

•  
• lollie (62)
• [2006-03-11 6:28]

Hi Carmela,
Very nice shot with an impressive pov, I like it very much.

Steph.