Windmill

Critiques [Translate]

•      
• sebcz (869)
• [2006-10-11 12:11]
•  [Show CommentHide Comment]

•  
• wenqing (11591)
• [2006-10-11 12:21]

love the mood created josine :)
the comp and colors look good
i don't mind the grain and noise, cause thats just the camera :)
nice work

•  
• cleocat (4228)
• [2006-10-11 13:38]

I like the noise/grain. It gives the pic that old painting look. Great colours and great focus on the solitary windmills. This is stunning.

•  
• GreenBaron (36940)
• [2006-10-11 13:39]
• - [workshop] [compare]

Hoi Josine,
I like this kind of sunsets in a techo surrounding. The windmill is nicely contrasting agains the sky. One thing, the image is a little pixelated. Refer my WS to see the difference.

Hans


Thanks for your comment on my photo Touch Down!

•  
• Mrlittle (4770)
• [2006-10-11 15:54]

Hallo Josine.
Een ondergaande zon is al gouw mooi, dus de compositie bepaald het geheel. Deze is goed geslaagd en erg mooi.
Groet Frans

•  
• BenF (2987)
• [2006-10-11 16:35]

Hello Josine,
Beautiful shot, great colour and
good composition.
Wish I could see that for myself.
TFS
BEN

•  
• Janone (16986)
• [2006-10-11 17:48]

Good composition, its looks very silent, so can't hear the noise. lol
Jan

•  
• ajnviper (932)
• [2006-10-12 1:04]

I like your composition!
Sky is great.... well done on this capture Josie...!

•  
• kokos101 (24564)
• [2006-10-12 8:26]

hi josine!
agree with bk, i don't mind the noise, because, colors and composition and silhouettes is great
TFS
zoran

points tomorrow

•  
• Refugee (23654)
• [2006-10-12 15:23]

Hi Josine...I guess Seb didn't read your notes. I find it interesting that when some people step away from their normal type of shots and load an image such as this they attarct so many negative comments. Well done for being so brave. Good colour, superb silhouettes and well composed. TFS,
David
Hibernation Over

•  
• SkyF (6138)
• [2006-10-12 15:32]

Hello Josine,
this shot is very well composed I like the POV and the wonderful silouhette of the windmill. I do like the grain in this shot, but I think it would have more impact if the contrast would be a bit darker.
Well done.
Sky

•  
• jan515 (13272)
• [2006-10-13 5:31]

Hello Josine,
A wonderful composition of the Windmill in addition that wonderful Sunset, perfect details and an effect wonderful of the picture. Very good work.
Would congratulate.
Janusz

**/tomorrow sorry

•  
• JohnTulip (36180)
• [2006-10-14 8:16]

Hoi Joos
Tjonge wat een mooie nightshot. Als ik de reacties lees heb je voor en tegenstanders met het wat 'korrelig zijn' van de foto. Wel ik had het ook zo gedaan, het geeft een speciaal effect. Groetjes
uit het Haagje van ons
John

•  
• DuFrank (146)
• [2006-10-14 19:25]
•  [Show CommentHide Comment] - [workshop] [compare]

•  
• Viking (4383)
• [2006-10-16 16:34]

Nice composition Joos. Good colours, sharpnes, details and POV. Take care :-)
Rob

•  
• Silke (22368)
• [2006-10-17 6:33]

Superb shot and Green Baron's WS is excellent, making your fine composition a better final. Great colours and comp with a nice delicate frame. Thanks to both of you
Silke

•  
• Photograph2u (14484)
• [2006-10-17 8:11]

Hi Josine, a nice windmill captured here in the nice sunset.

I like the form of T it makes here.

Very well done! Yan :)

ps: many thx for your crit on "Window Reflections, Street Saint-Amable".

pl

•  
• vsinopoulos (12936)
• [2006-10-17 13:19]

I like the lovely colors and composition. The grain gives a nice original effect and I like it!
Well done!
Vassilis

•  
• lucbus (10464)
• [2006-10-17 20:14]

Hi Josine.
I like these great colors and the nice silhouettes of the windmills. It's very calm & quiet. Very beautiful photo.
Luc

•  
• harpya (31183)
• [2006-10-22 20:02]

Beautiful sunset, adore the colors
the tones, the details, and his work,
Congratulations, big visual!

Sérgio

•  
• erdna (5075)
• [2006-10-22 21:25]

Hi Josine,

This is a very good cpture of a magnificent sunset, captured in your frame with good composition. My feeling is that the noise reduces the dramatic effect of the lights on the sky.

Thank you for your comments on my photo, "Turning to Gold". I appreciate it.

Andre'

•  
• durrani (1688)
• [2006-10-24 6:14]
• - [workshop] [compare]

Hello Josine
Amazing composition and a fantastic shot. The colors are warm as well as cool too. the silhouettes are very interesting.
The noise and grain is no such problem as it is shot in low light.

tfs
Shahbaz

PS
I am posting a workshop hope you don't mind it.

•  
• cstathoulis (13305)
• [2006-10-24 7:00]

Hi Josine,

Despite the noise, your composition is full of lovely colours and creates a great, romantic atmosphere!! Nice POV and contrast!
Well done!

Constantinos

•  
• hay_kes (34381)
• [2006-10-26 7:33]

Hi Josine,
Superb sunset shot.Colours, light and silhouette are excellent.Well composed.TFS.

hAyAti

•  
• law (1764)
• [2006-10-26 9:38]

Nice composition Josine. I like the mood. Beautiful... :D

•  
• Emma (8286)
• [2006-10-26 11:52]

Hello Josine,
The composition is are excellent the colors wonderful. Very good work and good perspective.
Would congratulate.
Eva

•  
• izler (4013)
• [2006-10-31 1:53]

hi josine
here is beautiful sunset photo. composition, point of view, sunset colours-tones and using of light are great. thanks for sharing
regards
izler

•  
• pablominto (27106)
• [2006-10-31 2:14]

Hello Josine,
A fine dynamic composition!
A bit too noisy for my taste, but good colours...
Greetings,
Pablo -

•  
• ixtanbul7 (4622)
• [2006-11-04 11:45]

a little blure but it is superb...i like the colors... TFS

•  
• sleger (3549)
• [2006-11-08 5:44]
• - [workshop] [compare]

This is the modern age windmill. Personnaly, I think the good old windmills were better looking.
I like how the picture was taken so that we see the silhouette of the windmill opposing a nice cloudy and yellowish/redish sky. We have the four elements in this picture (wind, fire, earth and air).

Sylvain

•  
• vandana2923 (22017)
• [2006-11-08 17:19]

Hi Josine,

Wonderful capture of sunset and colors. Love the composition. TFS. Vandana

•  
• captainsgirl (6499)
• [2006-11-12 22:18]

beautiful colors, and a very peaceful photo. This windmills sure are giants..great shot. TFS
Donna :o)


thanks for your comments on my Still life Teddy..:o)

•  
• macgarret1 (1260)
• [2006-11-23 11:00]

A good moody picture Josine. You have captured the sky perfectly and the composition, with the (not so traditional) windmill is great too!
Good Luck!
Bill

•  
• chrisJ (26305)
• [2006-11-24 5:31]

Hi Josine

Yes, there is some grain, but aside from that minor technical imperfection, mood definitely rules here! Wonderful composition, with the silhouetted wind turbine blades, & superb warm sunset colours. Tfs!

•  
• Janice (25920)
• [2006-12-07 22:56]

Hi Josine, your wonderful looks awesome. I like Han's workshop, he has removed all the noise. But the colours and composition are superb. TFS
Janice

•  
• amitbiz (1496)
• [2007-01-22 6:45]

Hi,
I feel its little noisy..but overall its a good shot.
Amit

•  
• jacojvr (4027)
• [2007-01-28 9:34]

stunning photo Josine - perfect light, very well exposed and I love the silhouette of the windmill

jaco

•  
• Silvio2006 (24118)
• [2007-02-01 13:03]

Ciao Josine, wonderful windmill at sunset, splendid light and colors, very well done, ciao Silvio

•  
• s_a_s_h_a (2180)
• [2007-02-15 7:06]

Hi Josine,
It's a beautiful shot, great colors and
good composition.
Very good work
Alex

•  
• anjhello (4471)
• [2007-05-04 21:45]

Anjhello Scoring System:
DOF - 3 POV - 3 CREATIVITY - 3 COMPOSITION - 3
LIGHTING - 2 SHARPNESS - 1 COLORS - 2
PRESENTATION - 1

Average: 2.25

Range:
1 point: Average < 1.99
2 points: Average > 2.00

Scoring System:
1 Good 2 Better 3 Best

tfs!

•  
• twin (7065)
• [2007-06-09 14:30]

very nice silhuettes with wonderful colors BG...
beautiful image...
well done.. :)

•  
• Urfaust (9835)
• [2007-08-25 18:40]

ciao josine.. it's an image of full mood.. the windmill is without life.. it looks to wait for something or someone.. the light is perfect with great colors at sunset.. i like this work.. well done!
ciao Marco

•  
• salmi (4732)
• [2007-10-19 1:29]

Hello Josine,
Lovely picture, good compo and colors, but a little to noisy. Thanks!
Mihaela

•  
• copadonat (4023)
• [2007-10-29 13:27]

Josine

bello atardecer y colores t felicito

nat

•  
• HaBeMa (3026)
• [2007-11-22 9:58]

Hi dear Josine;I know windmill,sunset and windmill together very good nature view....
Habema.
:-]

•  
• limba3 (10374)
• [2007-12-12 16:55]

Hi
Excellent idea of this shot.Beautiful colours.
Congratulations.
TFS
Anna

•  
• Hormon_Manyer (1938)
• [2007-12-24 8:48]

Hi Joos,
Very nice composition and colors, but I myself am not really into grainy sky. I can't help thinking this noise (or at least a part of it) was "created" while re-sizing. If You'd like to avoid it, try to use gaussian blur on the sky - but this is probably You know by Yourself.
Except for the grain / noise this is a great photo.
Merry X-mas, respectfully Yours, László