Magnolia

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• TheMystic (5760)
• [2006-12-05 16:19]

Nice details and subtle colors. Effective border and good crop for a well balanced composition.
You hung on to this shot for quite some time before posting: what else are you hiding?
Cheers
Otto

•  
• izmirli (15435)
• [2006-12-05 16:20]

merhaba dear rob
very good macro photo.very good ping flowers and light.well done.
best regards.
gürkan akçakır.

•  
• Juliet (9476)
• [2006-12-05 16:41]
• [+]

Hi Rob,
OHHHHH I can smell how lovely this is. Nice capture on this magnolia. Very SHARP and CRISP with beautiful lighting. Well done and TFS Julie

•  
• shelbeesmom (33494)
• [2006-12-05 16:47]

WOW Rob! This is AWESOME! I have one of these trees in my yard! Wonderful tree! Blooms in January! We call it a "pink MAgnolia" or a "Tulip Tree"...
Nice!
B-)
Linda

•  
• Beger (15123)
• [2006-12-05 16:58]

Hi Rob,
Magnolias are rare here, cause our too hard climate. But thanks to your photo, I have the pleasure to admire them. Very beautiful image with delicate colors and a sweet filtered light. Bravo! Annie

•  
• jan515 (14124)
• [2006-12-05 17:30]

Hello Rob,
Good composition and a very interesting picture. I like so forming pictures, very interesting picture of nature. The colors
are wonderful. Would congratulate.
Janusz

•  
• SkyF (6138)
• [2006-12-05 20:07]

Hi Rob,
this shot is wonderful, you did an excellent job on composition and the capture. POV, sharpness and colors are beautiful. Very nice framing also.
Sky

•  
• c_rapp (6618)
• [2006-12-06 0:53]

Beautiful!!! The colors and details perfect. TFS
Christan

•  
• suzley (6780)
• [2006-12-06 5:07]

Hi Rob

.....a vision of beauty. Amazing in its clearness and clarity, a biggg weldone.
Stv

•  
• vandana2923 (22122)
• [2006-12-06 6:15]

Hello Robert
Wow this is a perfect flower Rob, I like the way you show the soft colours and surrounded by this good black frame. TFS :
Vandana

•  
• cstathoulis (13307)
• [2006-12-06 6:18]

Hi Rob,

WOW!! What a wonderful flower portrait!!! I really like the POV and softness!! Nice DOF and lighting!

Very well done and TFS
Constantinos

•  
• PierreFrigon (15457)
• [2006-12-06 7:28]

Beautiful shot. Very sharp and clear. Lovely colors.
TFS.
Pierre
:) later

•  
• wkshelton (8572)
• [2006-12-06 8:27]

Hello Rob

Hello Rob, Excllent work, great details very crisp, Nicly composed and capture photo perfect colors Bg POV DOf excellent work,

TFS Kyle

•  
• sak (2167)
• [2006-12-06 8:41]

Hi Rob,
Beautiful flower captured very well. Nice soft colours. I like it. Well done.

•  
• JohnTulip (36194)
• [2006-12-06 16:12]

Hola Roberto ..
que bellisma amici .. heel mooi Rob, goede framing
Doei
John

•  
• lucbus (10484)
• [2006-12-07 7:22]

Hi Rob,
Magnolia are so beautiful and they are always a sign of the spring. I like your photo that represent them very well with the beautiful colors and their softness. Very well done.
Luc

•  
• kokos101 (25126)
• [2006-12-07 9:56]

hello rob!
very beautiful photo of this magnolia. great colors.
tfs
zoran

pt

•  
• deains (4650)
• [2006-12-07 9:58]

Great view of this magnolia bloom! Lighting seems perfect to show it off! Don

•  
• cleocat (4228)
• [2006-12-07 16:44]

A favourite flower of mine. Excellent capture. It looks very soft and fragile.

•  
• Refugee (24939)
• [2006-12-08 14:55]

I hope you didn't water the magnolia Rob :). Excellent capture, good natural colour and fine detail. TFS,
David

Many thanks for your comment on ‘Fashion’

•  
• Claudine (0)
• [2006-12-08 18:37]

Hello Rob,
This is a very nice macro of this flower. You caught excellent details in a nice POV and composition. My only nit is this noise seen, espcially in BG... Anyway, this is a very nice post. Thanks,
Claudine

•  
• Josine (4069)
• [2006-12-09 2:13]

Rob wat mooi! Een plaatje in een plaatje :-) Doei
Joos

•  
• perryhooter (25960)
• [2006-12-10 13:02]

Hello Rob!

Well done. Crystal clear shot with natural colors and a straight forward composition and framing. A beauty (*_^)
Regards,
Robert

•  
• tucancr (2954)
• [2006-12-16 0:16]

Beautiful magnolia, the texture, colors and dof are very well presented. Great picture.
Regards,
Iris

•  
• katya534 (5538)
• [2006-12-16 23:24]

Lovely composition of this beautiful and delicate flower. Very well done.

Katya
P.S. Points later.

•  
• dreams (47)
• [2006-12-25 10:27]

tres jolie compo.
belle photo
bravo

•  
• chocolate29 (2607)
• [2007-01-02 23:34]

Hi Rob - A happy new year to you. These magnolias are lovely, I like the soft delicate colours, the DOF, and the positioning of the blossom just a tiny bit off-center. Well done! - Cheers, Cordelia

•  
• vsinopoulos (13071)
• [2007-01-03 13:07]

Hi Rob,
Very nice pastel colors and great lighting. Dof and sharpness excellent!
Well done,
Vassilis

•  
• orkhan (3526)
• [2007-01-03 13:09]

Nice macro, Rob ! Sharp and clear
TFS

:) later

•  
• chrisJ (28077)
• [2007-01-15 2:07]

Hi Rob

Wonderful sharpness & shallow dof in this superb macro shot of the flower. Tfs!

•  
• Silke (23860)
• [2007-01-15 9:42]

This is a stunning image, Rob. Great colours, perfect composition, nice frame, excellent POV and dof.
TFS
silke

•  
• sleger (3549)
• [2007-01-15 18:56]

Hello Rob

I like the softness in this picture. The wite line around the frame adds a touch of delicacy. It's nice to have nice flowers along the autoroute. At least when your car breaks down you have something nice to look at while waiting for the towing.

Sylvain

•  
• Janone (17933)
• [2007-01-18 6:34]

Hallo Rob.
Echte voorjaarsbloeier. Mooi plaatje, zit wel wat ruis in.
Jan
ola Rob.
Bedankt voor jou comment.
Je bent wel zuining met zelf posten. Kost niks hier hoor. Grappie.
Jan

•  
• Photograph2u (14504)
• [2007-01-18 21:59]

Hello dear Rob, Magnolias are so beautiful, they adorn my stained glass window door.

This is a very nice close-up and we see all the details of it. Nice colours.

I am allready looking forward to next springs.

Very well done! Take care, Yan :)

ps: thank you very much for your visit and critique in "Tropical Garden - Plaza Hotel, Quebec". I am very pleased that you like it :)

•  
• sugah_bear69 (4354)
• [2007-02-05 23:13]

Hi Rob,
You have captured one of my favorite flowers and made it look delicate and beautiful. Great lighting and colors, composition and calarity are on the spot!
thanks for sharing,
Fran

•  
• ajnviper (932)
• [2007-02-05 23:33]

I like the soft colors in this flower
how are the Rob guy?... :)

•  
• Pops71 (2089)
• [2007-02-23 21:57]

Hi Rob,
Wonderful Magnolia. Great sharpness of details and very pretty soft colors. I like the composition and the DOF.
TFS
Have a great weekend
Pierre

•  
• copadonat (4134)
• [2007-03-05 10:29]

Saludos Rob

El enfoque y la iluminación bien lograda te felicito

Nat

•  
• macgarret1 (1264)
• [2007-03-11 19:28]

Nice, subdued lighting here Rob, it suites th delicate subject perfectly I think. Lovely colours and framing as well.
Best wishes
Bill

•  
• pablominto (27422)
• [2007-03-21 11:07]

Hello Rob,
Good colours and details in this delicate flower!
Well composed presentation, good focus!
Greetings,
Pablo -

•  
• Hendrika (17760)
• [2007-03-28 4:49]

Hi Rob,
als ik mijn hoofd een beetje draai zit ik tegen een gigantisch grote magnolia aan te kijken met de ochtendzon erop. Dus ik stap zo even naar buiten voor een foto.
Ik zie wel dat ik niet net zoals jij in de hartjes kan kijken, dat maakt jouw foto wel erg mooi.
TFS
Els
:)follow

•  
• geterdone (755)
• [2007-03-29 6:44]

Hi Rob,
This is very nice. Great coloring, detailed but soft textures. Bg is nicely OOF just enough to keep it interesting. Good compo. Well seen and taken Rob. TFS Lyndon

•  
• Jacqueline (1880)
• [2007-03-31 5:56]

Hai Rob,
Deze magnolia is schitterend, Alleen jammer dat ze altijd maar zo kort in bloei staan, een echte lentebode,
Fijn weekend,
Gr, Jacqueline

•  
• anjhello (4529)
• [2007-05-28 2:07]

Anjhello Scoring System:
DOF - 3 POV - 3 CREATIVITY - 3 COMPOSITION - 3
LIGHTING - 2 SHARPNESS - 3 COLORS - 2

Average: 2.71

Range:
1 point: Average < 1.99
2 points: Average > 2.00

Scoring System:
1 Good 2 Better 3 Best

tfs!

•  
• gunershot (11704)
• [2007-07-08 14:06]

Hi, Rob,
Excellent shot.
Nice colours.
Perfect macro.
Thanks for sharing.
M.D.Seyfettin Güner.

•  
• abramhowitz (776)
• [2007-07-27 13:25]
• [+]

Nice to meet you rob,
i allways wanted to have one of this in my hand,the day of my wedding.
A so special flower.
Hope to see you again and thanks for share this beauty.

•  
• kbeall (3546)
• [2007-11-07 3:29]

Hi Rob,
The first pink magnolia I've seen! (All seem to be white in my area.) A very nice capture and placement of this graceful blossom in the frame.
Take care,
Karen

•  
• Hormon_Manyer (2055)
• [2007-11-10 3:01]

Hi Rob,
Great photo of this mediterranean / subtropical tree. Maybe the camera should have been moved left a bit, in order not to crop the other flower on the left + to place the main theme more right. But otherwise I like Your image, in spite of the closest, unsharp petals. Tfs, regards, László

•  
• salmi (4732)
• [2007-11-10 8:58]

Hello Rob,
Beautiful magnolia, great composition and colors. I miss spring...:).
Thanks!
Mihaela

•  
• jvachon (2163)
• [2008-09-24 3:59]

hello Rob,
This gorgeous flower was featured today and what a beauty.
I love the soft colours, and lighting.
Nicely composed and framed.
I have added it to my favourites.
TFS, Joni