Pillar II (tribute to Emanuela)

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• tet (3625)
• [2006-01-06 8:56]

Hi Francesco,

I like this a lot more that the colored version. I like the reflections on the mirror. Something different.
Good PP work aswell.

Tet

•  
• brettf1 (4852)
• [2006-01-06 9:02]

WOW Francesco! This is awesome!!! A great graphical image that draws the viewer in to get lost in the shapes and reflections. Outstanding contrasts really bring out the graphical nature of this shot. You have been taught well and it is a great tribute to a fine tutor. Very well done and coached!

Keep having fun Francesco!
Peace and Love as always!
Kevin

•  
• tropicalrips (0)
• [2006-01-06 9:03]

good compo and POV francesco :)
this looks better then the color version, well seen shot

•  
• dada (6560)
• [2006-01-06 9:16]

great POV, Francesco! amaizing graphism! great choice the BW

congratulations!
anca

•  
• starbug (177)
• [2006-01-06 9:22]

great graphical result- this is a very well chosen point of view for this effect, and of coourse, changing it into b&w was a perfect choice.
best regards

•  
• SylFondacci (14127)
• [2006-01-06 9:33]

Hi Francesco !
Great shot of the Dome, interesting POV, B&W is a good idea !
I was there in August and you can have a look at this I posted :
The funnel
Congrats
Sylvie

•  
• magda_indigo (31245)
• [2006-01-06 9:34]
• - [workshop] [compare] [+]

Hi, I love the symmetry, a spectacular comp and view, interesting too, thanx, M, (*_*)

•  
• mukesh (4777)
• [2006-01-06 9:47]

Magnificent Francesco - it is like a piece of intriguing puzzle. You keep trying figure out what's where. Like the extreme sharpness of your take. Well done
Mukesh

•  
• Eru (2760)
• [2006-01-06 10:14]

Hello Francesco,

Pure graphical image here!
Original POV, your traitment works very effective here.
Bravo!

Marc.

•  
• hojper (4087)
• [2006-01-06 10:30]
• - [workshop] [compare]

This photo reminded me of one I had seen on TrekEarth and which had been inverted to create a funny effect. Here it is. So I tried a workshop which I hope you will like.

•  
• Werewolf (26142)
• [2006-01-06 12:04]

Woa! It remember me some science fiction scene! That structure seem very big and with style! That's cool and well presented!!

•  
• emanuela (1013)
• [2006-01-06 13:35]
• [+]

super francesco........ and thanks, we all learn from all!

take care
e

•  
• metall (2956)
• [2006-01-06 13:57]
• [+]

WOW. GRAPHICAL SHOT, Really this is professional shot. I just can say my congrats

•  
• Refugee (25542)
• [2006-01-06 13:59]

Well thanks Francesco that didn't do my vertigo any good :). Wonderful image, brilliant PP work. I do agree with Magda saying that the balustrade looked funny. Congratulations and the effect you achieved.
David
PS many thanks for the comment on my 'Willow'

•  
• pathy (1734)
• [2006-01-06 14:27]

belle réalisation photographique ! je pense que c'est une tres bonne idée de l'avoir prise en noir et blanc cela renforce le jeu des reflets

•  
• sayans (806)
• [2006-01-06 14:57]

Hi Francesco
A nice graphical shot. Loved the composition and the tone a lot.
Thanks
Sayan

•  
• Tintin (1982)
• [2006-01-06 19:02]

Very well done, Francesco. Interesting POV that creates a disorienting effect. Nice conversion to B&W which seems to adds a lot to this picture. Nice PP work. Excellent!

•  
• Ilir (5119)
• [2006-01-06 21:52]

Simply excellent dedication. Wonderful.

Alban

•  
• LuciG (8681)
• [2006-01-07 11:47]
• [2] [+]

CIAO FRANCESCO :)
I really enjoy your work! You did a great Job on this. First, I think that the b&w was the perfect choice because it emphasizes all the lines in order to create an abstract and graphical composition! Then of course, Your POV is very inovative and original, which gives to the image a little bonus :)
Congratulations.
Luci

•  
• Mirty (275)
• [2006-01-07 12:18]
• [+]

Ciao Francesco,
another brilliant shot of yours. I particularly like this. Other have said it all, great POV, perfect choice of B&W, good detail.
Keep them coming! :)
Martina

•  
• plank (2073)
• [2006-01-08 6:57]

Hi Francesco!
A very intresting and nice shot. I like a lot.
TFS
Tibor

•  
• paul_bk (0)
• [2006-01-08 7:01]

also teh original is a good picture, but here the PP adds a lot..... you transformed this view in a strange space..... like a sci-fi scene
Paolo

•  
• letr (6780)
• [2006-01-08 15:52]

Like the pocv here Francesco , pitty about the reiling but magda did a good job getting rid of it ..excellent choice for the B/W here !

•  
• mr_pedro (4644)
• [2006-01-10 16:08]
• [+]

This is a beautiful shot, congratulations! B&W works very good and I like all the lines, shapes and reflections. It also has the diagonals starting in the top corners which lead the eye into the picture.

TFS,
Pedro

•  
• Redrubin (0)
• [2006-01-11 1:11]

Proprio bella questa qua.
compliments!

•  
• iliannak (3480)
• [2006-01-11 9:17]
• [+]

wow ... amazing POV Francesco :o)
lovely PP as well but the original you started from is very good as well
very well seen and captured
ili

•  
• jacobo (4875)
• [2006-01-11 10:54]

I like this very much. Good lesson.
Jacobo

•  
• Janone (0)
• [2006-01-15 15:29]

Great shot, Made me feel dizzy.
Jan

•  
• wenqing (11857)
• [2006-07-27 11:48]

excellent POV Francesco :)
good choice of b/w here
X

•  
• Anna- (652)
• [2007-04-24 15:08]

Ciao Francesco,
ringrazio anch'io Emanuela perchè l'inquadratura è veramente originale e grafica :)
Ottima la conversione in B&N, mi piace moltissimo l'effetto creato dalle riflessioni
Anna