Trees die standing 2

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• suzley (6786)
• [2005-03-17 3:25]

Hi Slawek

This is a big shot here. Very very good indeed. The feel is frighteningly good. I hope you can post the original in WS for us to see what if any was done to this masterpiece. Very well done.

Steve

•  
• paul_bk (0)
• [2005-03-17 3:35]

what a beautifull image... dreamlike....
I like your compo with a central position of the trunk in contrast with the horizontal cut of other elements.
Well done
Paolo

•  
• chiaraluna (2560)
• [2005-03-17 3:40]

this is truly amazing... it looks like a Caspar David Friedrich painting... so powerful and intense and brilliantly realized... such a dark mysterious mood you've created.. must go into my favorites right now! just wonderfull Slawek.. fantastic shot! :) - Ayda

•  
• ophildeleau (297)
• [2005-03-17 5:01]

an unreal image
appearance, colors are heavy
great

•  
• ladybug8381 (48)
• [2005-03-17 5:19]

this is an intense shot. the processing has added a very dramatic effect to the clouds which i think compliments the mood of the photo very well.

•  
• coenraad (128)
• [2005-03-17 5:25]

Awesome shot you took here , this is magazine quality. I would have liked to get some more detail in your note though.
Regards C

•  
• pattyjy (1130)
• [2005-03-17 5:52]

Beauté et mystère. J'aime bcp la tonalité. Très réussi. Amitié, Patty.

•  
• laine (877)
• [2005-03-17 7:04]

spooky
have you done any adjustments or it really was in such colours? i take you did some PP..
anyhow, great work! love the colour

•  
• Werewolf (26142)
• [2005-03-17 7:07]

Fascinating! I can imagine the lightning who kill him! And the clouds give a wonderfull dramatic scene!

•  
• nova (8653)
• [2005-03-17 7:32]

Magnificent! Excellent composition! Nice monochrome effect! Well done!

•  
• cloverstar (0)
• [2005-03-17 8:42]

The whole tree this time. Very good composition allowing so much of that lovely sky. The blue colour to the image is fantastic. Well done, Slawek.

•  
• Maru (0)
• [2005-03-17 9:07]

Fantastic scenry you captured here, Slawek!
It's like a dream.. with that silhouette and those amazing grey colors..
Perfect contrast and use of light.
Very well done!!
Marisa

•  
• jrj (724)
• [2005-03-17 9:23]

I like this very graphical compo of the dying tree. Excellent post work, very good use of light. Well done Slawek

•  
• padre (4035)
• [2005-03-17 9:37]

This has a strong mood Slawek. The tint works well here. B

•  
• mukesh (4777)
• [2005-03-17 10:05]

But what is the story Slavek? Was it stuck by bolt from the sky... abruptly and brutally? Or destroyed mercilessly by the flash flood... or.. So dramatic that questions keep flashing in your mind. Yes - Suzley said it right - it is frighteningly good.

•  
• markgong (448)
• [2005-03-17 11:03]

Wow, what a great find Slawek! Good choice of monochrome for this shot. Great mood and simple composition makes this shot very effective. Good work!

•  
• vheus (249)
• [2005-03-17 12:32]

nothing to add,
wonderful,deep...
thank you and,
bravo...

•  
• Saiz (0)
• [2005-03-17 15:09]

Un arbre abattu dans la désolation la plus grisante ... belle photo!

•  
• lady33 (1283)
• [2005-03-17 16:24]

very nice :-))

•  
• cleopatra (1152)
• [2005-03-17 19:59]

This is a winner. The tone is perfectly adapted to the sadness of the situation. Félicitations

•  
• gazo (504)
• [2005-03-17 23:20]

Good monochromatic picture. **

•  
• reddevil (0)
• [2005-03-18 16:55]

Great shot! I like the atmosphere around this picture, strange and very powerful. Good job.

•  
• jimzzz (493)
• [2005-03-20 20:52]

Very great shot Slawek. I like the composition and the special color of your B&W. Congratulation.

•  
• Sin (209)
• [2005-03-22 7:16]

good job..
congratulations!

•  
• edie (0)
• [2005-03-22 7:28]

Great atmosphere, colour is fantastic.I like it very very much.
Bravo!

•  
• noyan (153)
• [2005-03-23 16:14]

great composition. is this the original picture or is there some PP? it is a wonderful shot!!

•  
• strangiato (0)
• [2005-03-24 22:23]

Fantastic work here. Both the composition and the post processing are excellent. A very moody and original photo. This setting would work very well in a horror film.
One minor flaw though: the horizon seems to be slightly tilted. But who cares, it will go to my favourites.

•  
• xav (409)
• [2005-04-02 19:26]

Amazing light !!! Great tones and the composition is very nice. I very like this shot, my favorite of the day !
S.

•  
• brzuchma (3763)
• [2005-04-17 16:29]

swietna fotka, bardzo fajna kompozycja i kolor, bardzo mi sie podoba,
pozdrawiam
Marek

•  
• recepyuksel (6554)
• [2005-05-02 12:51]

Soğuk ve ölümü ifade için çok iyi bir tonlama. Bravo

•  
• Quark (66)
• [2005-05-02 14:08]

The tree is unhappy, that's what I see in this shot, also with the dramatic mood around created by the darker tones, it's a great shot, Slawek, nice done !

•  
• Jaimeson (193)
• [2005-09-02 8:28]

What a powerful image. I like the negative effect...great job!

•  
• BecStar (107)
• [2006-01-07 6:15]

Hey Slawek, congratulations on such a beautiful image! You have really captured the mood well. It's almost haunting! Did you do any PP? Well done! Bex

•  
• SampraS (46)
• [2006-01-19 18:26]
• - [workshop] [compare]

Szefie!!
to jest potezna fotka!!

BRAWO + Swietnie wyszukany kadr
Pozdrawiam
Adam

pozwolilem sobie na workshop

•  
• elkab (739)
• [2006-01-20 15:24]

Super światło i kolorystyka, niesamowita głębia mimo płaskiego krajobrazu, no i to drzewo, któremu ręce opadły...

pozdrawiam
ela

•  
• lollie (62)
• [2006-01-24 7:48]

Simply superb Slawek!
Steph.

•  
• nonna (446)
• [2006-03-28 14:59]

Hauntingly beautiful. Both the point of view that you have selected and the monochromatic colour scheme add nicely to the mood of the photo.

•  
• bratani (94)
• [2007-02-13 4:11]

Cześć Sławek,
Fajne zdjęcie, tajemnicza sceneria.
Pozdrawiam - bratAni

•  
• shelbeesmom (48152)
• [2007-04-19 10:23]

this is a SUPERB shot! Excellent moodiness, love the blue tones here, the simplicity, yet it holds alot! Very nice!
Linda
B-)

•  
• njmv79 (344)
• [2007-04-19 10:49]

Hello Slawek,
Beautiful picture and an amazing work you have done, congratulations.
Nelson