Life

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• darimarc (1330)
• [2005-08-05 4:25]

Przejmujące...

•  
• zto (262)
• [2005-08-05 4:31]

Beautifull. SImple but yet so expressive. Wonderfull low key and great contrast. Good title too. Welcome to TL Dorota.

•  
• colorpw (10)
• [2005-08-05 5:11]

very nice shot, and even the title:life. in chinese culture, we say to see through one person's hand, to got to know his life, and here without telling anything, ppl will get the story already

•  
• brzuchma (3763)
• [2005-08-05 5:38]

mówi więcej niż pokazane

•  
• drymd29 (7621)
• [2005-08-05 6:09]

Hardly to see as a thumb but the big view is great; a wonderful expression of life and labour. I make it a favorite. Capturing and saying this with that few elements is genious.
This picture is your first in here? Very promising, congratulations.

Thanks Dorota,
Huub

•  
• msadventure (20)
• [2005-08-05 8:00]

Welcome.
Very strong photograph. I like the compo and detail. The lighting is just right and details extraordinary.
Looking forward for your posts.

•  
• law (1764)
• [2005-08-05 9:16]

Hi Dorota,

Love the picture. Nice composition and good lighting. Just from looking at the hand, it gives me a feeling of lives' hardship and true labour especially the detailed wrinkles and grease on the hand. Living in this world is really hard.

I prefer if you cropped a bit of the black area on the left hand side so that the main subject can be focused properly and centralized. Anyway, I still love the picture.

Welcome to TL. Thanks for sharing, Lawrence.

•  
• chounet1 (107)
• [2005-08-05 9:23]

Image d'une très grande force. Splendide.
Michel

•  
• padre (4035)
• [2005-08-05 9:26]

Now that is a shot! Bravo! B

•  
• maleentjeh (66)
• [2005-08-05 9:29]

Powerful image ! Welcome to TL

Hope to see lots more of your pictures here.

Marleen

•  
• Maru (0)
• [2005-08-05 16:26]

Hi Dorota!
this is an extraordinary photograph!!!
the tone, the details and the way you play with the negative space around the hand makes a remarkable composition.
This hand is telling us a whole life story! And you had the ability of capturing all in one shot. Congratulations!
and welcome to TL :)
Marisa

•  
• erdaest (0)
• [2005-08-05 17:50]

Wow! Dorota, incredible composition. Extremely powerful. Very well though out. Meticulous details. The dirt, the strong laborious hands, the piece of bread! Color is a very good choice for this. EXCELLENT WORK!

•  
• dimeola (854)
• [2005-08-08 10:12]

Droga Doroto,

Dziekuje za twoja opinie nt. mojego ostatniego zdjecia. Jesli chodzi o moje techniczne niedociagniecia, to mowiac szczerze utkane z nich cale moje fotografowanie... Chce budowac swoj jak na razie skromny warsztat.
Jjednakze technika sama w sobie nie bedzie nigdy moim celem. Do fotografii podchodze dosyc intuicyjnie wykorzystujac wieksze doswiadczenie z dziedziny malarstwa i rysunku szukajac w niej tego "czegos" co czasem trudno zamknac w ramy techniki. Lubie w fotografii nieprzewidywalnosc. Rozumiem jednakze co masz na mysli i zgadzam sie z toba.
Jesli chodzi o twoje zdjecie to jest naprawde ciekawe. Ladna ostrosc, ciekawy pomysl. Ma dosyc naturalistyczny wydzwiek...
Osobiscie troche inaczej bym je wykadrowal i byc moze zrezygnowalbym z kolorow.

pozdrawiam i zycze radosci z fotografowania co najmniej tak wielkiej jak moja

dimeola

•  
• Elfik (2441)
• [2005-08-09 9:35]

znakomite...
i juz je ulubiłam tam, gdzie miałam okazje;-))

•  
• LeHo (2440)
• [2005-08-10 14:11]

chleba naszego powszedniego daj nam dzisiaj ... witaj Doroto! tu, na większym formacie prezentuje sie ta fotografia jeszcze bardziej przejmująco ...

•  
• spike1 (4321)
• [2005-08-11 8:38]

Excellent photo Dorota. Very simple content, but extremely expressive.

•  
• cloverstar (0)
• [2005-08-11 10:16]

Znakomita fotografia. lubię powód (przedmiot; podległy) i droga (środek) to jest ciemne. Dobrze zrobiony. Byłby wy pamiętacie (pilnować) piszący na maszynie uwagę dla USA uczyć się (poznawać; dowiadywać się) jak wy zrobił ten (to), sprawiać przyjemność (proszę). *Diana*

•  
• France (77)
• [2005-08-11 11:26]

It's more than a photo, this picture tells us so many things about misery, hard work, the hunger, the coal mines ... Sharpness and black color are perfect to reinforce the idea of hardness of life. By looking at your the first 4 photographs, I note that you have already a very personal style, very poignant, serious and a perfect control of the image. Why don't you tell us more about you (note and presentation) ?

•  
• bscheller (32)
• [2005-08-11 11:37]

wow, stunning. the lighting and the overall effect of it. thats one piece of bread, i would not want to eat. this is truely a wonderful shot, the reason why this person's hands are so dirty, are because, they work hard to get enough money to buy a loaf of bread. the hands look tired and worn.

super!
pozdr.
-Bartek

•  
• motzart (2107)
• [2005-08-23 13:00]

Super !!!!

•  
• Werewolf (26142)
• [2005-09-15 10:45]

Gee! I was shure i was already give a note on that one... Never too late! The effect is great! It make thinking immediately about hard conditions of work, or life! Very well realised!

•  
• btokaz (5744)
• [2005-09-19 2:34]

Piękne, przejmujące, symboliczne...

•  
• Serabi (1641)
• [2006-02-18 21:28]

Wspaniale!!! PRO!

•  
• andzia (991)
• [2006-08-05 3:59]

przejmujace...

•  
• jms77 (33)
• [2006-12-10 4:08]

świetne... po prostu

•  
• mesquens1 (17663)
• [2007-05-16 9:59]

Olá Dorota, ´
Grande e emocionante foto.
As cores combinam bem com o sentido que você emprestou à sua foto: ânsia de sobrevivência.
Obrigado por compartilhar.
Raimundo

•  
• Pioforsky (1693)
• [2007-05-23 12:45]

Bravo Dorota!
I love your reflection about life in this photo.
Great one!
Un saludo
Edén

•  
• Rissiepit (702)
• [2008-03-10 0:31]

Wonderful Dorota, this picture says so much...!