redrose

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• chrisJ (42534)
• [2006-01-08 6:04]

Hi rca

Impressive graphism of the red rose against the dark bg, which appears to make the color even more luminous. Good sharpness & compo. Congratulations!

•  
• katya534 (5546)
• [2006-01-08 6:29]

Excellent quality. I like your choice of background and frame.

•      
• kitflorendo (0)
• [2006-01-08 6:48]

Approaching perfect. There's a little 'thing' right on the bottom edge that could have been taken out? Thereafter, I very happy with the lighting and the composition. 9.85/10

•  
• LenScapp (35)
• [2006-01-08 9:51]

Beautifully lit but I don't think the large black empty space on the left helps this particular photograph in any way. Perhaps if you had moved the rose over a little and slanted it, it may work better.
Barry

•  
• lucbus (10317)
• [2006-01-08 10:57]

Very beautiful photo. The composition with the dark background is excellent with a great lighting which gives superb colors. Well done
Luc

•  
• LunaSun (142)
• [2006-01-08 11:48]

Très Joli et très sensuel!
Passe un bon dimanche!
Alain

•  
• duckpond (202)
• [2006-01-08 14:45]
• [+]

Nice shot, good idea. Good composition, colours and lighting.

The shot maybe needs to be cropped a bit on the left and please include a note. It would be interesting to hear how you did it. Cool

TFS

•  
• LuciG (8681)
• [2006-01-08 14:47]

WOW .. you are very creative to handle with books and rome lamp in order to create such a beautiful picture! You emphasize all the tenderness and beauty this rose could offer! The colors are great as are the textures!
Congratulations.
Luci

•  
• thomaspilatus (283)
• [2006-01-08 17:44]

Very well done. I like the idea of putting the rose out of the center.
regards, Tom

•  
• marmottelolo (1011)
• [2006-01-21 0:42]

bonjour
tres belle rose rouge et bon travail pour le fond noir.laurent

•  
• rgagnon (2211)
• [2006-03-03 21:29]

dans répéter tout ce qui a été dit concernant le fond, l'éclairage et le cadrage... simplement: bravo!

•  
• lilimih33 (17867)
• [2006-10-10 18:38]

Hello rca! Beautiful roses, with good background and frame! Ciao! Lili