The Ghost Island

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• jimmyjimmy (810)
• [2009-04-24 6:46]

Hello Francis

Ready for framimg, Great alteration with this photo. I would try another one without so much blur. Still good Composition.

Regards
Jimmy

•  
• luckybry (6309)
• [2009-04-24 7:02]

hi Francis very atmospheric work looks realy good i like the blur effect you have given and Jimmy doesn,t that the beuty of this site everyone see a shot different you have a nice pov and the colours are good tfs
regards bryan

•  
• roges (4149)
• [2009-04-24 8:33]

Hi Francis !

A splendid landscape, the colors are excellent and contrast their very nice.
How to play is very original and I love it.
Congratulations and expect and more!
A beautiful day,
Adrian

•  
• BigSid (5)
• [2009-04-24 9:31]

I agree with Jimmy and go for less blur

•  
• Fotocop (326)
• [2009-04-24 10:52]

Hello Francis,
very well done, beautiful colors and nice effect. This church growing from the trees is really wonderful.
Ciao, Elena

•  
• cobra112 (6644)
• [2009-04-24 12:50]

Hi Francis. In my opinion little blur is not a problem. It's a contribution for general great scenografic atmosphere. I like it.

Roberto

•  
• cunejo200 (16919)
• [2009-04-24 14:35]

Francis,
The pp work certainly makes the image ghostly. Honestly I wish I can duplicate this effect. Regards and keep on experimenting. Danilo

•  
• rlrad (830)
• [2009-04-24 18:44]

Hi Francis Xavier,

I think your experiment was a success, as it is garnering differing opinions here. I like the blurring and distortion, it sort of sets a mood. The composition is great, too. One thing I might do if I had arrived at this conclusion is omit the title over the image, but that is just my own opinion.

Great job!
Reed Radcliffe
St. Louis, Missouri, USA

•  
• Silvio2006 (42300)
• [2009-04-25 9:54]

Ciao Francis Xavier, fascinating composition, fantastic work in PP, wonderful effect, very well done, have a good week end, ciao Silvio

•  
• ayse51 (19700)
• [2009-04-25 14:23]

Hi Francis,
beautiful shot.Like a dream,like a poem.TFS.Necla.

•  
• macromania (8762)
• [2009-04-25 14:37]

Lovely effect Francis, very moody.

Regards Mark :)

•  
• MLINES (8446)
• [2009-05-01 23:58]

Hi Francis, A dreamy rendition of this special place by the lake. Very well created and presented. I like the framing especially. TFS. Murray.

•  
• ramon (3039)
• [2009-05-23 6:28]

Hi Francis,

A very creative composition, i like the blurred vignette.
Great mood you have created here. Well done...

TFS
Ramon