Shell Set

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• GreenBaron (40274)
• [2006-10-31 16:14]

Hi Karan,
Again a great composition in B&W from your hand. Like the differeces in contrast although I think some need additional lighting. Overall very well done great job!
Hans

•  
• Claudine (0)
• [2006-10-31 16:19]

I think this is very interesting and beautiful. I do not even know how to do collage :) Each image is very good with excellent details and lightning. I like the use of B&W here and this nice contrast. Well done! The Tate Gallery... It makes me so nostalgic; I went there when I was 18 years old; many years ago and I miss England so much... Wish I can return someday :) Thanks,
Claudine

•  
• wishnugaruda (12290)
• [2006-10-31 16:22]

Hi Karan,
it's a beautiful arrangement, I like the impressive work in black/white, wonderful, thanks
Sabine - wishnugaruda

•  
• Ejtaan (9804)
• [2006-10-31 16:23]

Lovely collage Karan!
Nice sharp images and of course the B/W. Well done all in all

Cheers!
Anneke

•  
• cleocat (4230)
• [2006-10-31 16:28]

Interestinng shapes and textures. Good background choices. Very well put together. A bit more light maybe as Hans suggested but nevertheless a good effort.

•  
• juanjo (3220)
• [2006-10-31 16:41]

Hello Karan
another nice composition in BW of different shells

regards

jjo

•  
• hay_kes (39336)
• [2006-10-31 16:47]

Hi Karan,
Another very beautiful collage.Very good B&W compo.Nice idea and work.Regards.


hAyAti

•  
• captainsgirl (6637)
• [2006-10-31 17:12]

its beautiful, nice black and white and great closeups of all the shells..nice job.. TFS
Donna :o)

•  
• Tintin (1982)
• [2006-10-31 18:58]

I always find montage interesting, Karan, but it is an art to get it perfect. I like this one but I am not certain about the choice of the middle picture on the left as it has a different angle from all of the other ones. All of the pictures have a different line where the black start and I am wondering if it would have been better if all of them would have been the same. I do like the vertical composition and each of the pictures are interesting by themselves. Well done!

•  
• Suerte (3286)
• [2006-11-01 3:58]

great compo, BW is a good idea!
tfs

•  
• joebatista (5403)
• [2006-11-01 4:47]

Wonderful collage you've got here Karan

The Black and White works perfectly here.

Bravo
TFS

•  
• SunToucher (5882)
• [2006-11-01 5:48]

Hi karan,
I could wait for the explanation of your collages on TN, or just look at TL....:)
I agree with the idea of the artist and it really works well in all of your photos. I have to agree with Suzanne on the one in the middle being different from the rest. I also feel that having the 'horizon' on the same level would help create a more smooth transition from one photo to an other. But the result is beautiful and the idea is well executed.
TFS,
Niek

•  
• pablominto (27436)
• [2006-11-01 5:54]

Hello Karan,
A very pleasant collage!
Images are sharp with fine details, all captured in fine light...
Textbook quality, even if I'm curious about the colours...
Greetings,
Pablo -

•  
• wenqing (11695)
• [2006-11-06 8:27]

another excellent image for the series karan :)
my favorite here would be the bottom left photo :) i think the shape and patterns would make some beautiful macros :)

•  
• ange (1210)
• [2006-11-12 7:58]

Hello Karan
I think you are right... the objets are more interesting and attractive to look at, grouped together in a collage.
I like very much this composition. I like more your choice of bacgrounds in this photo.
Regards
Angeles

•  
• marietom (1258)
• [2006-11-16 14:29]

bel assemblage, bien présenté.
Marie