Postcard From Selkirk

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• cjjc_jules (3545)
• [2008-10-09 0:47]

excellent photo collage, very interesting photos. tfs-jon

•  
• luckybry (1547)
• [2008-10-09 0:48]

nice work Derek like this one good collage well done

•  
• Jan (4029)
• [2008-10-09 0:51]

Woow, a real postcard!! Good work! I love the view of the valley!! Very beautiful and very sharp!

Well done!
Janneke

•  
• Hendrika (18754)
• [2008-10-09 1:03]

Hi Derek,

You live in a beautiful town then.

Each and every picture on this card is worthy of a posting - you should sell this one to the tourist office - would work great.

TFS
Els

•  
• WhiteKnight (2617)
• [2008-10-09 1:31]

4 very good seperate photos in an interesting and very postcardlike collage - very good..
David

•  
• rychem (2889)
• [2008-10-09 2:02]

Hi,
4 photos - one theme. I like the idea, perfect colage
compliments
Ryszard

•  
• lrw1966 (0)
• [2008-10-09 2:18]

Derek Hi:
Wonderfully beautiful home town, amazing collection, very well composed and presented
Larry
USA-tfs

•  
• Janice (28419)
• [2008-10-09 2:27]

Well done Derek
Good shots here and I like how oyu have put the 4 photos together.
It looks a very interesting place too.
Well done
Janice

•  
• Jonela (549)
• [2008-10-09 2:28]

Hi Derek,
Brilliantly put together it is a homage to Selkirk and as Janneke has said a real postcard. The colours in this collage are great well done and tfs.
Regards
Jon

•  
• Dawn (16417)
• [2008-10-09 2:49]

Beautiful collage.. well done..your postcard is lovely..great presentation, and interesting photos.

Cheers
Dawn.

•  
• y2kosan (1506)
• [2008-10-09 4:10]

a good compilation of photos.
well composed. colors and texture are great.
compliments, TFS.
y2koSan

•  
• yanm (7239)
• [2008-10-09 4:14]

Not only one but 5 picture....ummmm i should do that :):)

Yan

•  
• John_F_Kennedy (8900)
• [2008-10-09 4:43]

A great experiment! Works wonderfully for the theme. Wonderful shots.
Best wishes,
Achim

•  
• Danert (3706)
• [2008-10-09 6:31]

Hi Derek
You have made a real postcard . You did a good PP work in a perfect style . You made a good choice for your pictures .
Daniel

•  
• chefcop (4341)
• [2008-10-09 9:18]

You should get this one published and printed Derek, you will make a fortune :-)

Post card perfect

Peter

•  
• Dot (6414)
• [2008-10-09 10:43]

HI Derek
A very good presentation of all these pictures which are so
educative.
Good job and a great one for the theme.
Dot

•  
• glint (2842)
• [2008-10-09 11:37]

hello Derek,
a very well put together montage of pictures to make up your postccard. It really is professional looking.Interesting note.We have a Common Riding in Annan too although it is known as the Riding of the Marches (boundaries).
Bev
It seems there is a good contingent of Selkirk folk on TL.

•  
• RSK (3872)
• [2008-10-09 11:40]

Hi Derek,more than fits the theme,you'll probaly have a call from your local tourist office, asking if you would give them permission to produce it for promoting that area.

Ron

•  
• Royaldevon (9239)
• [2008-10-09 13:21]

Hello Derek,

A very realistic postcard showing detailed views of Selkirk. Your pp skills have really worked well here. I can see the Tourist Board of your area contacting you in the near future!!!

Kind regards,
Bev :-)

•  
• tyro (3096)
• [2008-10-09 16:04]
• [+]

Hello, Derek.

Excellent!

This one is perfect! Not wishing to reiterate what you said about my contribution, nonetheless I find each of the pictures in this collage/montage to be perfect. Not only that, each of the pictures depicts a separate theme or place from the town. Very well presented indeed!

I'm a bit of a beginner (tyro) at these collages - how did you combine the images together like this - I tried PSE6 but still found it a bit of a struggle - is there a knack or is it just a matter of trial and error?

Kind Regards,

John.

•  
• jvachon (2703)
• [2008-10-09 20:31]

Hello Derek,
What an interesting collage. Each of these shots could have been posted.
Very well composed with great colour and detail.
A fine job, Derek!
TFS, Joni

•  
• boomcat (12261)
• [2008-10-10 0:26]

hello Derek,

this one can sell :) i like how you combine all 4 shots into one.. very good work.. i wish i can do something like this.. all are sharp.. my fav. are the 2 in the middle.. a very good contribution.. tfs..

regards, terry

•  
• korbee (9342)
• [2008-10-10 12:50]

Looks like a typical 1970s card,lovely job Derek.
jan