St. Giles Cathedral

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• colvert (4018)
• [2009-02-07 12:57]
• [+]

A fantastic shot, Tom ; I like too much.Your ppwork is great and everthing of this work is worth congratulations; amazing colour too which increases the fantasting and amazing effect.

•  
• espanek (6586)
• [2009-02-07 12:58]
• [+]

Hello Tom.
This is amazing work showing your great imagination and PP skills. Excellent tones, dramatic sky. I love the waves crashing against the rocks.
I think that the only issue here is the proportion between the cathedral and the lighthouse. They are very close to each other and the lighthouse seems to be smaller than a statue in front of the church.
TFS
Wojciech

•  
• wishnugaruda (14480)
• [2009-02-07 13:12]

Fantastic work, Tom, I love this result, it's real artwork this way, congrats - perfect!
Greetings
Sabine - wishnugaruda

•  
• hifimusicdai (4753)
• [2009-02-07 13:39]

I am sure that many Christians would think that this is not only an interesting composition but also speaks to the mission of the church in the world ie a refuge and built on the rock ages.
Lovely work. TFS
warm regards
David

•  
• timtim (9550)
• [2009-02-07 13:53]

WOW amazing PP
TFS

•      
• luckybry (6289)
• [2009-02-07 14:26]

hi To this is abolsutley amazing your pp work is awsome never thought i would see stGiles like this tfs
regards bryan

•  
• ChuFer (2210)
• [2009-02-07 14:57]

Tanto el original come este de la imagen sorprende por la elevada calidad de la composición, los colores y esa luz tan especial...saludos

•  
• falcon53 (571)
• [2009-02-07 14:59]

Beautifully crisp shot. Very moody and imaginative.

•  
• jentt (3679)
• [2009-02-07 15:13]

Hello Tom
An Excellent PP work for a fantastic result. Really superb.
Regards
Antoine

•  
• SergionrSilva (1652)
• [2009-02-07 15:45]

Hello tom
Great work
Very good
Congratulations
Sergio

•  
• bigil (2091)
• [2009-02-07 16:22]

Génial comme idée, j'aime beaucoup.
Le ciel, la mer, le château, le vent, la lumière du phare, tous y est.
Beau travail.
Gilles

•  
• Janice (32868)
• [2009-02-07 17:54]

Kia ora ToM
I catch you here again!! How are you?
And EXCELLENT PP work - Many hours?? Yes! The result is great - clever you.
It looks like a very deep dark stormy night and the Cathedral looks like it lives on the rocks and waves.
Well done
Janice

•  
• Leica (2099)
• [2009-02-07 21:03]

You're are still the best Tom. Cheers!

•  
• perryhooter (27341)
• [2009-02-07 21:43]

Hello Tom!

Impressive post processing work . Hats off for a brilliant end result. Well wothed the efforts.

Bravo!
Robert

•  
• macromania (8762)
• [2009-02-07 22:50]

Superb PP Tom.... great detail.

Regards Mark :)

•  
• chefcop (4638)
• [2009-02-07 23:16]

Very imaginitive ToM love the post processing, mind you quite like the original too.

Your hours of toil have certainly resulted in a very creative image. Think this one should be sent off to a couple of magazines :-)

Nice one.

Peter

•  
• boomcat (16869)
• [2009-02-08 0:12]

your long hour is worth it, Tom.. i love the result.. fantastic work.. good one.. tfs..

regards, terry

•  
• dunav1 (1879)
• [2009-02-08 0:52]

Hi Tom
Interesting and creative work,This is lovely image and composition!
Excellent effect,
Well done
Regards
Z.

•  
• Adri (11068)
• [2009-02-08 0:59]

Hi Tom,
This is GREAT!
Superb PP-work!
I can't add any more......

TFS and greetings from Netherlands,
Adri

•  
• thor68 (4534)
• [2009-02-08 5:35]

yeah, that is the real spirit of TL! :-) awesome pp-job and a wonderful piece of art.
excellent idea & stunning job, thor.

•  
• Dawn (17508)
• [2009-02-12 21:25]
• [+]

Hey Tom, what beautiful PP work you have done here.. well done to you, and I can imagine how long you must have sat in your chair at your computer!! my hand would have been totally numb! if I had of sat that long.. but I would not get this result, that you have.

It looks amazing! and I have walked up this street(workshop Photo) here and seen this beautiful building.

I do love the light from the lighthouse and how it beams out to the waves.

Top marks my friend.

Kia Ora
Dawn

•  
• iso (27859)
• [2009-03-06 10:03]

Poor me I thought it was the reality. My way to write you the excellent and original work you did Tom. My sincere congratulations for this work. My hat off.

Iso.

•  
• Virginia_Denny (326)
• [2009-03-30 8:07]
• [+]

Hi Tom, Great work.. I see you are a real artist as well as a photographer. Thank you for taking the time to show your origial shot in Workshop.. I would have also seen the original background shot too..
tfs
Denny