Action in air...

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• harpya (9643)
• [2009-09-12 6:50]

Ciao George


Great action shot of my friend ...
Undoubtedly, it is a beautiful Air Show!
I like the formation of planes,
Also a very nice contrast image.
Excellent perspective and amazing colors too.
Very well done,

Have a nice weekend,

Sergio

•  
• mvdisco (35221)
• [2009-09-12 6:54]

Hi George,
What a great action shot with U.S. Navy Blue Angels,
wanderful caught of view and details of the place,
beautiful colors and light well presented and composed..
very well done.
Michel

•  
• werdir (2655)
• [2009-09-12 7:40]

Hi George,

This is an interesting shot and in my opinion a bit frightening. I realize that it is an airshow, but when you think of the destruction these warbirds can bring, having the crowds so close provides quite a bit of perspective. A well-timed shot with perfect sharpenss and DOF.

Regards,
Werner

•  
• alper2702 (2484)
• [2009-09-12 7:43]
• [+]

Zdravo George!
impresivna fotka...odlicna kompozicija sa super svetlom...
avioni su super pozicionirani...
pozdrav,
Alper

•  
• tatara (3779)
• [2009-09-12 7:46]
• [+]

Ako je akcenat akcije na ovoj fotografiji trebao da padne na avione ..tj ako su oni u sredistu paznje,onda je ovo potpuni promasaj...slika je u pozadini prepuna sa kojekakvim nepotrebnim detaljima koji odvlace paznju od onoga sto si ti u osnovi hteo da prikazes kao glavne atribute na ovoj fotografiji...
moje misljenje i moje bodovanje...
JozefK

•  
• milas (32729)
• [2009-09-12 7:54]

merhaba george...
estetik ve güzel bir konpozisyon, bayram falanmı oldu, şehir planlamacısının o güzel yeri otoparka ayırmasını anlayamadım ama vardır bi bildiği demekki, selamlar

•  
• nicou (20364)
• [2009-09-12 9:56]

Hello,

Très impressionnat cette iamge, cette patrouille en plein vol, quel captage parfait, ils passent très près des bâtiment, génaile image.

Bravo et amitié

Nicou

•  
• fransx (7956)
• [2009-09-12 11:21]

Hi George,
Great timing for this action shot!
Very sharp perspective with plenty of interest!
The four planes are followed attentively by the spectators!
Great lighting and accurate sharpness!
Very neatly presented in an elegant format.
Regards,

Francis Xavier

•  
• john1 (1490)
• [2009-09-12 12:52]

Hello george,

Great action shot, the Blue Angels I thinks.
Excellent details and sharpness, beautifull perspective and colors.
Very good presentation and composition.
Have a good sunday, my friend.
john

•  
• kanton (5272)
• [2009-09-12 14:42]

Zdravo George!
Wonderfully captured,an action scene!
perfect colours and pov,fine lighting
and details!
Regards and tfs
Kostas

•      
• GreenBaron (48812)
• [2009-09-12 14:45]
• [+]

Hi George,
Something is wrong with this picture. Those A/F-18's of the Blue Angles appears out of proportions to me. It looks fully unnatural in respect of position and size. Is this a manipulated photo? Do you have the exif file of this image?
Hans

•  
• tanburi (37010)
• [2009-09-12 16:54]

Hello George,
Well balanced compğosition, clear details and saturated colors.
TFS
Selahattin E

•  
• chrisJ (42081)
• [2009-09-13 1:52]

Hi George

Good repetition of the 4 jet planes top left, with excelelnt colour, sharpness & framing. Nice graphism & an informative note, too. Tfs!

•  
• Alfonso (3133)
• [2009-09-13 2:39]

prywitanne George!
nice one!very good action shot!fantastic!It's very difficult to catch that moment!=)
ALiaksandr

•  
• bracasha75 (11323)
• [2009-09-13 10:35]

Zdravo Dzordz
Canada je zaista lepa zemlja sa vel;ikim brojem dogadanja tokom godine i ovo je jedan od tih
Svaka cast staro momce
Pozdrav,Braca

•  
• shaukatmi (3553)
• [2009-09-13 15:03]

Hi, George. Great action photo with accurate timing for the formation. I went to see the Seahawks fly in Seattle but could not get the timing right. The photo as always is well composed sharp and a informative note is very helpful.

•  
• tedesse (3945)
• [2009-09-13 15:24]

Witaj!
Wspanialy widok,fantastycznie prezentuja sie te mysliwce w akcji.
Piekne kolory i ostrosc,ladne swiatlo.
Pozdrawiam
Tadeusz

•      
• WhiteKnight (7543)
• [2009-09-13 15:57]

Is this a copy and paste shot? if so you need to tell us this in your notes. I agree with Hans that it doesn't look right.

For starters the light on the F18s is different to the light on the crowd, secondly aero dispaly teams are not permitted to fly this low over a crowd, especially still pointing at the ground at such a low altitude.
Lastly, when I enlarge the image the spectators are looking at a different part of the sky - ie straight up and not over towards the F18s.

It's a nice idea but I do think you should be more up front about the pp.

David

•  
• Fortuna (18945)
• [2009-09-15 18:33]

Hello George,

Excellent daily life/action shot!
Very good light, contrast and sharpness!
Very well done!
Congratulations and TFS
Sergio