Blue City

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• Kilted-Arab (9477)
• [2009-03-16 16:27]

Hi Vincent - almost looks like a scene from some post-apocalyptic world with the pp work you've done. OI like the use of the tree trunk in the foregound - it adds depth, perspective and some natural framing. Cool image.

•  
• messenger1 (4142)
• [2009-03-16 16:38]

Great experiment, Vincent. The tree in the foreground is really interesting with all of its tones and textures. Love the composition and the b&w conversion - it all conveys a strong mood. Well done.

•  
• iderverg (731)
• [2009-03-16 17:37]

Hello Vincent ,

Une photo expérimentale vraiment interessante .

On peut y voir la progression du bitume et du béton sur l'état de nature ou la constatation d'un monde uniforme et monochrome.

Bien vu

laurent

•  
• mvdisco (34919)
• [2009-03-16 18:51]

Hi Vincent,
Excellent POV well taken picture,
nice contrast and light,
Excellent deep of field well presented.
compliments
Michel

•  
• Beger (19874)
• [2009-03-16 18:52]

Hi Vincent,
This composition and your PP work give a surrealistic mood at this city! I like when an image cans tell us a story! The use of the tree in foreground places us in at the heart of action, hidden behind this tree, we could be spies about a psychologic war in this mysterious city! :)
I like much the depth and the faded blue tones!
Bravo! Annie

•  
• lilimih33 (17552)
• [2009-03-16 19:09]

Hello Vincent!
Wonderful point of view and fantastic atmosphere!
Excellent the tone you choose!
Beautiful work!
Best regards!
Lili

•  
• kross1 (4376)
• [2009-03-16 19:45]

Hi Vincent,
I really like this view of San Francisco and the way you composed the shot with the Eucalyptus tree in FG. The PP work is very creative and gives the picture a different but very cool look to it. Very nicely done/
Regards,
Kevin

•  
• Yanush (629)
• [2009-03-16 20:11]

Hello Vincent
Great composition and PP.
Congratulations.
Janusz

•  
• kickback (11295)
• [2009-03-16 21:13]

always amazed at the great PP work you guys do, truly incredible, this has a great somber mood, perfect composition and tones are incredible,
awesome work,
thanks,
scott

•  
• rudla (2774)
• [2009-03-16 23:41]

I love it! Blue tones,great angle and the mood :)
Best regards,
V

•  
• Teresat (8431)
• [2009-03-17 0:57]

Bom dia vincent
what a great begin to a story.
Very well composed...
Delicious....
My regards
Teresat

•  
• lavan (3446)
• [2009-03-17 1:19]

nice shot
good scape
nice one
good experimental

•  
• nicou (20032)
• [2009-03-17 6:24]

Hello,

quel cadrage, la souche de cet arbre et en fond les superbe builinds, fantastique iamge, quel effet cela donne à l'ensemble, superbe.

bravo et amitié

Nicou

•  
• chrisJ (41791)
• [2009-03-17 6:30]

Hi Vincent

A superb result & it was strange to see so many eucalyptus trees (a native of Australia), in California. I felt right at home! A moody & atmospheric shot, with a superb tonal range. Tfs!

•  
• shelbeesmom (47712)
• [2009-03-17 10:14]

Hey..got interrupted last night before I could leave my critique! HAHA! I love this! The details on the FG and BG are great! Love that dramatic sky! Nice work on this! The blue tint is very nice also, it creates a mood!
B-)
Linda

•  
• WhiteKnight (7487)
• [2009-03-17 10:35]

Interesting pp Vincent - I like the silvery tone here.. The HDR merger has worked nicely and the composition is really very nice.. A good mix of rural v urban..

Good work
Rgds
David

•  
• trekks (13589)
• [2009-03-18 2:06]

hi Vincent

I find your new profile photo to be very good; please keep it stagnant for a long while! I really am puzzled why so many photographers are good but kept a below par profile photo?

A nice experimental shot of HDR view of the bay with the city in the BG. Sometimes it is experiments like these that make us learn more quickly.

tfs, bill

•  
• Kli (2000)
• [2009-03-18 12:48]

Bonjour Vincent,
J'ai vraiment l'impression d'être cachée derrière ce tronc et d'observer la ville au loin. Excellent POV.
Amicalement.

Pascalie.

•  
• rewshearer (20678)
• [2009-03-18 21:11]

Nice work, it gives the impression of a vast wall of ice or rock looming above the city; in fact with a little more playing around with aperture and composition you could almost have created that scenario!

Great job
Rew

•      
• pozaru (18952)
• [2009-03-19 7:23]

Impressive, very impressive !

thanks,
v

•  
• mbrito (11262)
• [2009-03-20 11:31]

Hello Vincent
This photo is simply amazing; the POV behind the tree in the left, and the difuse focus in the distance, is very cinematographic and reminds me a perspective of a «sniper» coming close to a city in a «post apocalyptic world». The atmosphere is a fantastic «gothic high-fantasy» emphasised by the blue tone and the dramtic sky and soft misty around the buidings.
Excelent. Vicent «Machinelove» at his best.
Have a great we, mb

•  
• tracer (7870)
• [2009-03-25 12:33]

i agree with the mood Vincent, one mighty fine mono conversion. contrast is excellent!

tfs

i a n