Wine Trio

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• ilouy (760)
• [2004-04-04 11:02]

Great idea! Very creative shot. First I thougt, on the thumbnail basis, that it was a post-processing "cut and paste" work! But, no, it's a well done setting-in-scene.
I think colors are a little bit "flat" and that the glass in front could be some more sharp, but no matter, I give smile for the idea!

•  
• KSD (84)
• [2004-04-04 13:04]

Great Picture.
Good idea.
I like your idea.

•  
• Derrick (0)
• [2004-04-04 14:50]

High points for creative thinking! Why dont you try using more subtle coloured lighting, perhaps even suspend a candle inside the glass? That would be an interesting twist.

•  
• Jep (585)
• [2004-04-04 15:39]

Oh very fine composition Michel - good idea and well done - I must try to think the same way, now we got this place to post and get critique.

•  
• cecile (315)
• [2004-04-04 16:50]

bienvu l'effet de perspective

•  
• ninadev (1043)
• [2004-04-04 19:50]

Bien pensé, bien vu et bien réalisé.... peut-être un peu terne comme couleur cependant.

•  
• creator (24)
• [2004-04-13 11:48]

how abstract! wish i had that idea... now i've got to find another great shot...

thumbs up ;-)

what did you do with the background? it seems that the floor fades over in the wall, or there's some kind of curve in it instead of straight walls?

•  
• yerevantsi (847)
• [2004-04-14 3:48]

Very nice composition and lighting efect.
The color saturation is moody and works.
You've used some kind of paper as background I think... Some note would be just great!
Well done

•      
• moketni (1485)
• [2004-05-28 1:24]

Very good composition, this is a very well thought out and executed shot, with excellent results, I like the wine in the last glass as well as the sepia colour.
A very pleasing shot, a note would have been nice.
::M::

•  
• philounet (94)
• [2004-06-23 15:52]

Original photo. Nice background. Great !

•  
• pdp (538)
• [2004-07-18 17:28]

A good idea well executed. I like it. Well done!

•  
• ruudblok (22307)
• [2005-06-02 7:20]

First I like the creativity second I like wine too. Before you start a photo like this you have to think and play, make a composition. Then you pick the best and ask yourself what thinks the rest of the world. I think its good.

•  
• Ejtaan (11247)
• [2009-08-15 13:33]

Not only creative Michel, but also well executed.
I think there is still a challenge for you here.
The reflections of the light(s) (the white spots) in the glasses. If there is a way to get rid of them you would have a perfect picture!

I really like how you focus on the third glass with the "wine" in it. Good work!

Cheers,
Anneke