Tobacco sky

Critiques [Translate]

•      
• wbriques (2520)
• [2009-10-19 10:35]
• [+]

Erwin,

Help me here. Why Tobacco city? Help this humble South American man.

The effect in the sky seems a little odd with the rest of the picture.
Cheers,
Wellington

•  
• rewshearer (20950)
• [2009-10-19 11:29]

I picked up one of those filters myself last month and it can deliver some great results. I like the simplicity of this shot, although I suspect if you'd aimed your camera lower - and given us less empty space in the fore and a little more tobacco sky - it would be even more powerful.
Rew

•  
• jackal (2887)
• [2009-10-19 12:29]
• [+]

Hi Erwin,
looks like the Aussie dust storm just hit Auckland. Is this done with a graduated lens filter or is it a PP effect?
Either way, the contrast from top to bottom seems to much for me but I do quite like the effect on the sky
cheers
Jack

•  
• lilimih33 (17875)
• [2009-10-19 14:43]

Hello Erwin!
You created a special atmosphere with your PP work!
Good detail and clarity in this picture!
Well done!
Best regards!
Lili

•  
• Janice (33174)
• [2009-10-19 18:19]

Hi Erwin
I certainly know that scene very well. But you show us it in such unusual colour tones.
The tobacco filter gives it a look as if a storm is coming. But I would have expected a tinge of the sky to show up in the water - I feel that is missing in the image.
Still, nice and sharp
TFS
Janice