Falling Tree make a Sound?

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• mikolaj_cava (13127)
• [2008-06-05 0:45]

Hello Janice! Mysterious forest. Nice lightness. Good natural colors. Perfect capture. Well done!

•  
• manujmehta (4717)
• [2008-06-05 0:52]

yes Janice
they do if you catch them at the right time
nice compo
lovely post dear
good shade of green
good lighting

regards
MAnuj MEhta

•  
• nishantdavid (1248)
• [2008-06-05 0:52]

Hello janice
A very authentic and creative addition to the theme.
A huge crushing sound is anticipated.
Great Shot
Well Done.
TFS

•  
• glint (2481)
• [2008-06-05 1:07]

Hello Janice,
my goodness me! philosophy sooo early (for us in the UK) in the morning. An interesting take of he meaning of sound.
regards
Bev

•  
• johnnymag (2271)
• [2008-06-05 1:32]

Hi Janice,

I can hear the Tui's tweeting in the trees! lovely image, and your note is very thought provoking even at this time in the morn. Well done and TFS,

John

•  
• Refugee (24138)
• [2008-06-05 2:18]
• [+]

But you would say yes Janice :)

Lovely light and colour in the image, well composed and fine detail. TFS,
David

•  
• John_F_Kennedy (8005)
• [2008-06-05 2:35]

Nice idea and good note too. Great composition with good light!
Best wishes,
Achim

•      
• pozaru (15853)
• [2008-06-05 2:49]

hmm, great idea; I like it !


thanks,
v

•  
• melanysherden (1711)
• [2008-06-05 3:10]

Hi dear Janice
Excellent idea for tyhe theme. Very intersting compo. Nice colours. Excellent forest
Best Wishes
Melany

•  
• Janone (17493)
• [2008-06-05 3:40]

Sound ? Didn't hear it, was no there.!
But it sure makes 'Sound', you show us this 'falling in love' picture, dear Janice.
BTW, None was there when the 'Big Bang' sounded, right ?
Hi ha ho.
Thanks for the sound, dear Janice. Your a treetimeslady.
Have a nice evening.
Jan

•  
• boomcat (10166)
• [2008-06-05 3:58]

of course it does, Janice.. even the birds are making noises flying away from it :) i guess it sound like t i m b e r r r but in more quiet way.. hehe me and my imagination :D

beautiful shot for today posting.. i like this beautiful green.. good job..

regards, terry

•  
• Mitra (7204)
• [2008-06-05 4:22]

Nice composition, good shade of green & lighting. Well done.
Mitra

•  
• Helkoryo (20664)
• [2008-06-05 4:31]

Hiya Janice

A wonderful capture here, excellent light with really good sharp detail and natural colour, Well seen and captured for the theme.

Your notes are absolutley superb! ;-)

TFS regards Helen

•  
• messenger1 (954)
• [2008-06-05 5:05]
• [+]

Hi, Janice -
Lovely photo, very funny note! Great shot of this lush forest. The subject tree makes a perfect diagonal across the frame. The colors are warm and natural and everything is nice and sharp.

I had a science teacher once whose answer to this question was, "No sound exists." Why? "Three elements are necessary to have sound: (1) the thing which causes the soundwaves to be produced; (2) the medium through which the waves travel (e.g. air, water); and, (3) a receptor (the eardrum). If any one of those elements is missing, then there cannot be said to have been a sound. In space, there is no air, and therefore, you can have a vibration and a receptor, but without the medium to transmit it, there is no sound." A pretty dry approach to a fun philosophical question, but there you have it. Have a great weekend -
Sandy

•  
• ttreen (14211)
• [2008-06-05 7:07]

LOL Very funny notes Janice
I loved reading each one.. I agree YES for the sound! Perfect idea for the theme....
The photo is really amazing! This place look so tropical and green! I keep looking and waiting for a dinosaur to wonder by :)


Tricia

•  
• Skepp (28)
• [2008-06-05 7:32]

Another Creative work Janice :)
Composition and the light are best !
Thanks a lot
Igori

•  
• lisapw1 (4993)
• [2008-06-05 8:29]

Janice, LOL! LOL!
This tops 'em all!! You note is hysterical. I've thought about this ancient riddle and many others... (when a cow laughs, does milk come out of it's nose? ..."herd" that one in a commercial)

Great addition to the theme. Lisa

•  
• PierreFrigon (15411)
• [2008-06-05 9:26]

Excellent entry for the theme.
Good sharpness and details.
TFS
Pierre

•  
• gajmar (683)
• [2008-06-05 10:07]

Hello Janice
Beautiful forest. The full picture of splendid colours and the excellent sharpness.Very curious description. I congratulate and I greet Mark

•  
• Silke (23100)
• [2008-06-05 10:08]

This is a wonderful idea for the theme!
Great composition, wonderfully peaceful mood
TFs
silke

•  
• Royaldevon (7808)
• [2008-06-05 14:15]

Hello Janice,

This is becoming a site, as interesting for its notes as its photographs!
That tree has a mouth!
Its shout will be heard miles away!

Fabulous composition, details and light.

Kind regards,
Bev :-)

•  
• miau (2988)
• [2008-06-05 16:09]

Bonjour Janice,
Ce sont d'abord les couleurs qui m'ont attiré dans ta photo. Elles sont magnifiques. La luminosité est, elle aussi, superbe et toute l'atmosphère qui en résulte pareillement.
Bravo pour la photo mais pour la note aussi!

Michel.

•  
• Kay01 (86)
• [2008-06-05 17:39]

Morning Janice.

Lovely photo of the bush. Just as it is.
Well done
Kay

•  
• puffy (16547)
• [2008-06-05 18:06]
• [+]

Hi Janice,

Lovely shot, I remember this "Forest" wonderful captured, I still can't get over how little it is but how "Ancient" it look, excellent place, great captured and composition, did someone just yelled "Timber...."? good shot!


Have a nice day,

Cheers,
Sweety

•  
• Hendrika (17052)
• [2008-06-05 22:42]

Hi Janice,

This absolutely is a more mysteriuous forrest then the woods we have here - also different trees. Love the atmosphere in the woods and I can find that in your picture.
As for sound, when I see a huge tree fallen over, then my imagination is big enough to immediately hear the sound it made when falling - that what you get for storing so many years of memories and experiences........
Absolutely love your note.

TFS both

Els

•  
• eosnut (6767)
• [2008-06-06 1:49]
• [+]

Hi Janice,
This is great, whenever I try these 'bush' shots, I get OE sky.
The lighting was good to you, nice detail and colour saturation throughout, well done.
As to the answer...if nobody is there to here it, we'll never know. If you were there, and it landed on you...it wouldn't matter;)
Heaven forbid,
Pete.

•  
• lrw1966 (2578)
• [2008-06-06 5:19]
• [+]

Janice Hi:
I saw this beautiful presentation for the theme yesterday and wanted to wait for points before responding. Wonderful composition with great colors, clarity and POV. An excellent note, as well. I hope you have an excellent weekend.
Larry
USA
TFS!

•  
• Dot (4966)
• [2008-06-06 5:47]

Hi Janice
Having lived 29 days in the ice storm of 1998 I can definitely vouch for the crackling sound trees make and it is scary especially at night.
Your composition is good and sharp giving us a nice oblique line. Good job
Dot
Later

•  
• wilth (1239)
• [2008-06-06 15:01]
• [+]

Hi Janice,
Great photo, nice light, color and depth and clarity....good job.
The note is just great and a wonderful companion to the photo and the philosophical question.
By the way, I've always felt that the answer is "how would you even know it fell", so why worry. :o)
TFS, good work and great addition to the theme.
Wilt

•  
• tsesler (3975)
• [2008-06-08 1:34]

Hi Janice,
excellent compo for the theme,
beautiful tones of green,
superb clarity and sharpnes,
welldone and tfs,
regards,
Taner
:) tomorrow

•  
• kvrnkiran (3139)
• [2008-06-09 20:16]

Hello Janice,

My answer is also Yes. You caught this tree very nicely. I like the diagonal composition and colors. Well seen and presented. TFS.

Kiran.

•  
• datis (489)
• [2008-06-10 12:01]
• [+]

Hi Janice.
Very clear and natural photo. It make a reality sense. I like jungle and suggest to you to visit the following link and check it out the Fiordland / New Zealand.

http://www.forests-forever.com/

Regards,
Daryoosh