<< Previous Next >>

do I need to go on a diet?


do I need to go on a diet?
Photo Information
Copyright: alper oztutar (twin) Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 446 W: 134 N: 196] (7145)
Genre: People
Medium: Black & White
Date Taken: 2006-03-12
Categories: Artwork
Camera: canon 350d
Photo Version: Original Version
Theme(s): Beauty, kobieta ze snu #6, kobieta ze snu [view contributor(s)]
Date Submitted: 2006-03-15 13:39
Viewed: 2754
Favorites: 3 [view]
Points: 101
[Note Guidelines] Photographer's Note
just the question that I ever hear from a female :)

even she does :))
Add Critique [Critiquing Guidelines] 
Only registered TrekLens members may write critiques.
Discussions
ThreadThread Starter Messages Updated
To Josine: :)twin 1 07-26 14:03
To SylFondacci: :)twin 1 01-30 13:37
To rychousmama: -- confused.Biance- 1 12-08 00:44
To rychousmama: :)twin 1 12-01 12:47
To wolbal: :)twin 1 03-15 16:07
To runningaaronds: :)twin 1 03-15 16:06
To Brzoza: :)twin 1 03-15 16:05
To gtinatl: :)twin 1 03-15 16:03
To caner: :)twin 1 03-15 15:18
To ABunce: :)twin 1 03-15 14:53
To surfacing: :))twin 1 03-15 14:06
To albyro: :)twin 1 03-15 14:02
To suzley: :)twin 1 03-15 14:02
To Serabi: :)twin 1 03-15 14:00
You must be logged in to start a discussion.

Critiques [Translate]

I would say definitely not! Interesting pose...

Errrrr no...

Hi Alper.

Eat something,

Great B/W. Love the pose...very unique. Well done.

S.

Hi Alper... very nice composition.....

Hi Alper,

does the question concerns you, or your model? :-D
If her, tell the lady it depends on her! :-) As of you.... please post any recent photo of youurs - we will see!

Pity you left us, nice to have you back! I hope this time you stay longer :-)

Nice shot, nice lights, nice relaxed pose. tfs

Marek

That such a woman would ask that question goes to show that is far too important a issue.

People should enjoy life, Your model as well! She doesn't need to worry.

Great shot, BTW!

Wow!
Nice compo.
Gosh, lovely.
Well Done.

Great model, nice pose, well presented!

GT

nice nice nice... :) good choice of colours (b&w is great!)good pose!
regards
Alicja:)

Alper,
Another great photo! She needs NO weight loss. She is perfect just the way she is. How do you do it???
Aaron

This is great! As close as it will get to fashion photography, I think. The monotones work great, and the good strong pose is excellent. Stunning.

  • Great 
  • Yug Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 223 W: 0 N: 93] (1860)
  • [2006-03-15 16:41]

Nice composition Alper. If you go....problems ahead! Good lightning and nice b&w. Good shut!
Guy

Hi Alper, great compo. need no diet! :)
cheers
ToM

  • Great 
  • fox- Gold Star Critiquer [C: 73 W: 8 N: 6] (537)
  • [2006-03-15 18:56]

wow!!!!!!!!!!!

Even if she did, and she doesn't, the answer should always be "No honey, you look great!"

Nice gray scale usage.

Ben.

Selam alper
Güzel çalışma.İlginç demeyeceğim.Son derece doğal.

Kerem

  • Great 
  • GlenC Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 142 W: 2 N: 99] (787)
  • [2006-03-15 21:13]

Cool... a very expressive and alive feeling image. Like the black and white and tones you went with work well. Nice jeans.... :)

Glen

  • Great 
  • Eru Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 259 W: 10 N: 83] (2704)
  • [2006-03-15 21:48]

Hello Alper,

Of course not!

Very particular composition, excellent idea. B/W is an excellent idea too.
TFS!

Marc.

In that position it's hard to say! But i suppose the answer is no! Having arms to the air bring a tension on the stomachal region ;)

IF you like living dangerously you can her that... But as a photo in B&W have reputation to better say the truth... I would be honest.

But as we know that there is alway's that question and if they know we will never say yes! Why are they ask? lol!

OK.. Now that i mix everything! I have to say it's a good work! It,'s the style of some jeans adds! :)

Very nice. Beatuful shot B/N.
Well done.

hi,

hmmm , no i think it's ok. no diet needed:) very sexy pose...

regards, pawel

Hi Alper,

Great photo, a good strong pose, B&W was a excellent choice. Congrats

Regards
Conrad

No, don't go on a diet, just loosen the belt a little... hey - I said just a little bit...

Nice work - great exposure and interesting crop. Just be careful not to 'cut' an image on a joint (wrist, elbow,...) as the limb might appear amputated. Lovely skin tones here as well. Model has a great figure-8 (or hour-glass) shape!

  • Great 
  • joker Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Silver Note Writer [C: 81 W: 17 N: 45] (889)
  • [2006-03-17 5:35]

This is the second post of Katya, I suppose. She is superb model - very artistic and expressive though I can not see her face here :). Her body speaks.
And of course you did a great job with light and composition too. Hope to find more of your work here.

Great detail.

Figure is nice too. No dieting needed. You got the right curves.

Well done.

TFS.

You are so good at such shots Alper! This one is great too. I like the light here, and she gave attractive pose.
And the diet? Umm yes she needs to go on diet if she really wants to wear low rise jeans :)))
-anonymous jealousy woman ;)

Hello Alper, I like the pose, the shine on the skin and on the jeans, also the higly contrasted tones of greys and b/w.

Very sexy.

Take care. Yan :)

There is no good answer to that question :) The safest thing to do is say "no" within less than a second.

This is a great PoV.

Ozgur

I like the way you see the woman body. Bravo!
Maurizio

  • Great 
  • thor68 Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 382 W: 85 N: 711] (4375)
  • [2006-05-26 17:13]

hi alper,
too bad they removed the other photo today,
i thought it was ok.
this one here is very nice, very sexy
and yes, it´s the question men hear very
often. *g*
excellent pose!
well done & take care, thor.

She so doesn't have to go on a diet. Her body is perfect...Good capture. I like her pose...

Thanks for sharing.

Hi Alper, what can I say... I like that kind of very graphic image pure black and white very well composed that give almost an impression of a drawing and at the same time so sexy and human. Great work! I love those curves so no... no diet! :-)
Patrick

gercekten harika bir model ile calismissin

Hi Alper, Very effective eye-catching pose. Original and creative. No diet neededhere. Good portrait for TL. Murray.

hell nah!!

Please don't! :o)

Good pose - and very good choice to go B/W...

Well you cant say much about this shot Alper, its just perfect!

Perfect curves !
excellant shot, ilike the framing and pov a lot.
Good be an advertise for something "slim"
Very well done
Hichem

Thihs is wonderful. Yes I have been asked that one too a few times in my life.And if this model seriously wants an answer to that question. Tell her she is doing just fine.
Brilliant photo Alper
s.

So while you condemn women for being conscious of their bodies and body size your photos only value women for exactly that: their bodies. I am so sick and tired of these photos that totally dehumanize women (you intentionally crop out their faces or heads (or parts of them) to make it easier to objectify them). Don't make nasty comments about women's image of their bodies and their selves when the only thing you think they are is JUST bodies. Geesh!
-Lara

  • Great 
  • shal Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 174 W: 46 N: 163] (1302)
  • [2006-12-02 4:50]

Hi Alper,
this is an excellent shot,
great POV, compo and B/W tones :D
very well managed :)
Cheers :D

  • Great 
  • Ivan Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 498 W: 104 N: 275] (3561)
  • [2006-12-02 7:40]

Hi Alper,
I am wondering, nice picture or nice model ? The two of them, of course ! Well contrasted, just enough humor to presented it. Well done !
Ivan

A damn good shot! :)

Hardly need to say it, the woman doesn't need to even consider dieting. Good pose, and I think the white background was a spectacular idea! And I must say the choice of attire is quite good, jeans never fail and a black top always works perfectly with a white background- now the blacks and whites make the skin all the more alluring, since the light adds such interesting hues to it. I suppose sexy would be an obvious comment? :S I'd say this would work well as a Calvin Klein add! This is a definition to the difference between male and female. :)

Well done Alper.

Biance.

  • Great 
  • Oscar Silver Star Critiquer [C: 13 W: 4 N: 7] (59)
  • [2006-12-10 5:57]

Great advert for jeans and jumper

If you do some cropping there are 3 further piccies here.

No she doesen't need to slim.

  • Great 
  • DAM Gold Star Critiquer [C: 513 W: 67 N: 268] (1110)
  • [2007-01-29 17:38]

Heck no diet is needed... I hear it from my daughters and wife. They all look good. Then when I go to work my female colleagues ask the same question. When I go to the gym, the girls are saying "I need to loose some weight" Nicely done. A very provocative and tastefully done photo.

DAM

No diet, no diet !!! Perfect like she is ! :))
Great shot ! Love it.
Do you mean that men never talk about having a diet ? ;)
Sylvie

wonderful Portrait here.
very nice POV and back pose from your model,
lighting and focus are wonderful.
tfs
Haldian

We can tell that your model is proud of her body.
Ofcourse she had to get to give you Vodka to make this excellent shot (yes I do read your photo advice to our friend John T ) :-) Goodphoto Alper. Nothing wrong here! (And as a woman I know when something is wrong!!) Greets from Holland
Josine

Alper what a good shot.. Could be a commercial for LEVI'S Jeans.
She is doing great, like many models we see in advertisements!
Compliments.. glad I found this one via the Forum.
Go in commercial photography!
John T

Hello my dear friend

The lady in question hs a beautiful figure and I feel maybe some people have mis read your interpretation of the title. I think this capture is superb and the B/W lends itself perfectly to the shot.

Wonderful work my friend. Dont change your style for anyone :-)

kidn regards Helen

Very classy photograph, Alper. I think you can tell from the reaction from other Treklensers - male and female and both here and on the forum, that there is nothing wrong with your photography. Keep it up and ignore the lunatic fringe.

its a great pic in black and white and funny title

Good work..
great perfect body ..
great shot
Rob

nice b/w photo
and nice body.

  • Great 
  • lavan Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 567 W: 2 N: 83] (2250)
  • [2008-09-16 1:45]

nice babe
good structure
nice capture

Calibration Check
















0123456789ABCDEF