Photography lesson

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• nsrq (0)
• [2006-04-03 18:55]
• [+]

Hi George
Great shot. Very well done. Good lighting, shadows and colours.
Regards
Nilton

•  
• retori (551)
• [2006-04-03 19:16]

i like it a lot...

i like the texture and the ilumination...


i like the story behind too

•  
• eyusuf (414)
• [2006-04-03 19:42]

nice detail texture and i like the lighting too.

•  
• rafelito (1026)
• [2006-04-03 20:35]

Wow.........George..is an excellent shot.
I like it, to much
Regards
Rafael

•  
• SkyF (6138)
• [2006-04-03 20:42]

Hi George,
lighting and colors are excellent. Nice details and great POV.
A wonderful composition.
TFS. Sky

•  
• TasmaniaC (5438)
• [2006-04-04 5:07]
• [+]

Hi Gearge, very well done, years did not take anything away from this peace of art. I hope that instructer is going through this site and learn something for a change.. tfs

Alaettin

•  
• Rajczakowski (3588)
• [2006-04-05 1:36]

Świetny opis. Ja mając wybór wolę jednak tak jabłka fotografować... są ciekawsze od tych pięknych wygłaskanych... i tak jest chyba ze wszystkim - z ludźmi też

•  
• surfacing (0)
• [2006-04-06 4:25]

Czesc Dżordż ;-P
ladna praca domowa. I kadr, i kolory, i oswietlenie. Szkoda, ze odrzucona - w koncu nie do jedzenia miala byc, tylko ogladania. Fajne sa te Twoje fotografie z tamtych czasow - przy okazji ciarki przechodza jak sie czyta o takich absurdach o jakich tutaj piszesz. A tak przeciez bylo! Czlowiek pomalu zapomina.... :-) Dzieki za przypomnienie. Dzieki za fajne zdjecie.

pozdrowienia

Marek

•  
• chiping59 (3448)
• [2006-04-06 10:11]

I won't do this kind of homeworks :)It is because I am a Chinese.Chinese like lucky and perfect things.But one thing I am sure,perfect apple doesn't have such beautiful "wrinkles"!Great shot!
Regards,
chiping

•  
• technogran (5525)
• [2006-04-10 15:34]

I find this photo appealing with the textures shown of the apple peel. The lighting is very good and I especially like the black negative space above the subject. To me it looks like an old painting.
Cheers
Joan

•  
• tournesol (12862)
• [2006-04-18 20:23]

Great note and great shot, George! Would have wished the underside of the apple was a bit more darker, but still, this image is quite powerful. Love the composition with plenty of dark space at the top. Well done!

•  
• Newair (42)
• [2006-04-20 23:46]

Great picture and great story. Thats unfortunate your instructor was blinded by politics. Great lighting. Thank you so much for sharing!

Alan

•  
• MultiCurious (304)
• [2006-05-10 4:17]

This is a really good shot..
I really like it..
Maybe the black "stripe" shouldnt be so visible.. Only a little soft light there; that would be great..
And I also think there is a hard lightening on the left side, and it is blurred a little..

:)

From Zuhal..

•      
• Riccardo5000 (1499)
• [2008-09-25 21:59]

Frankly George, I think you had an ignorant instructor. There's beauty in ugly things too and this photo is an example of that. It is strange indeed, but interesting at the same time. That's a really interesting story that goes with it too.

Richard

•  
• szatanowska (3001)
• [2008-09-27 7:52]

swietne detale i oswietlenie..genialne zdjecie!
NIe wiem jak bylo w socjalistycznej Polsce ale tego bym nie wyrzucila bo bardzo dobra prace domowa zrobiles!:)
Dobrze ze czasy sie zmienily:D
Pozdro z Italii

ania

•  
• joopschotsman (5317)
• [2008-09-28 8:42]

Hi George,
Great note ! and even greater photo.
Your PP gave it a super appereance.
greetings,
Joop!

•      
• CMJC (713)
• [2008-12-12 1:31]

this apple seams to bee in gold!
why must we alway explain choise... and at scholl! was your teatcher not a little anti-artistic and also just anti-objectiv....
pure reality is best than any great idea and words...