Le dilemme

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• Berlingo (1298)
• [2006-09-24 15:27]

Bonjour Claude,
Bel angle choisi ! J'aime beaucoup, même si j'aurais coupé un poil plus bas l'image en haut.
Stéphane

•  
• mortcdz (6085)
• [2006-09-24 15:28]

I love the lines in this picture, taking the eye this way then that way......
B&W works well here, making sure that the railway tracks are the points of interest with no distractions.
Thanks for sharing
Mark

•  
• shal (1302)
• [2006-09-24 15:36]

Hey Claude,
excellent proportions & lovely B/W tones that create mood :)
Great work :)
Cheers,
Vishal Sabharwal

•  
• orkhan (3526)
• [2006-09-24 15:49]

Bonsoir Claude,
Contrairement à Berlingo, j'aurais cupé un peu plus ne bas pour prendre un peu plus en haut.

•  
• hmm43 (644)
• [2006-09-24 15:55]

good composition. i like the fact that you used black and white as well since it takes away any distractions from the railroad tracks. good job
thanks for sharing
heather

•  
• Claudine (0)
• [2006-09-24 15:56]

Salut claude,
J'aime beaucoup ce titre qui illustre exactement ce que l'on ressent en regardant cette photo :) Merci,
Claudine

•  
• exuereb (1715)
• [2006-09-24 16:48]

Nice shot! I like the symmetry. Black and white really suits the picture.

•  
• Enric (5715)
• [2006-09-24 18:16]
•  [Show CommentHide Comment]

•  
• Timothy (1904)
• [2006-09-24 22:00]

Hi Claude!

Wonderful composition! The rail track are almost perfectly symmetrical... the lines produced are amazing. TFS

-Timothy

•  
• linus (9674)
• [2006-09-24 22:03]

Hi Claude,
Very nice composition. I am going to add this to on eof the themes on railways. Well done.
Sunil

•  
• hamed31568 (2418)
• [2006-09-25 0:50]

wow! fantastic composition.very attractive. well done.

•  
• crettaz (156)
• [2006-09-25 3:22]
•  [Show CommentHide Comment]

•  
• jdwyer264 (219)
• [2006-09-25 5:54]

A dilemma indeed, very sharp and intricate picture, hope you got out of there safely. TFS

•  
• foureur (17446)
• [2006-09-27 13:33]

Hello Clause
splendide compôsition, le titre va bien avec l'image.L'angle est trés bien
bravo

jojo

•  
• tomek_wap (4673)
• [2006-09-28 15:01]

A nice shot.
Good choice of b&w tone.

image kind of symetrical - nice effect.

Tom

•  
• sjurgensen (694)
• [2006-09-28 16:19]

I love the idea of this photo, really great. Naturally I don't want to know how you got this photo, you must have been on the tracks ;-)

Cheers

Steve

•  
• cqueror (0)
• [2006-09-29 10:25]

Hi Claude
Good composition, Lovely B/W tones
TFS

FaTiH

•  
• ceslou (4167)
• [2006-09-29 10:44]

Nicely seen Claude. very impressive image. the graphism is strong and your point of view is really good. the decision of making it b&w add more impacts.

•  
• SylFondacci (14032)
• [2006-09-29 10:51]

Bonjour Claude,
Une très belle photo pour illustrer un sujet auquel nous sommes bien souvent confrontés ... :)
Sylvie

•  
• Werewolf (26138)
• [2006-09-29 11:30]

En fait, il y a peut-être dilemme, mais on s'entend sur une chose au moins... Ce ne sera pas en ligne droite! Pour avoir un peu marché sur les rails cet été je n'ai pas eu a rencontrer de pareils dilemme par contre.
Bravo pour cette complexe trouvaille!

•  
• juyona (13816)
• [2006-09-29 18:29]

Claude que buen dilema... excelente y original foto. saludos

•  
• wenqing (11697)
• [2006-10-01 9:05]

love the comp here claude :)
excellent use of the frame
very good in b/w :)

•  
• marietom (1258)
• [2006-10-01 16:42]

joli jeu de lignes !
Marie

•  
• ilhanda (0)
• [2006-10-02 3:25]

Like to miror :)) [x]
ilhan

•  
• babett (72)
• [2006-10-02 12:25]

realy Great Photo!!!
symmetry is that feature witch eye-catch and b&w is the best way to express complexity structure..
cheers
kaś

•  
• idalio (251)
• [2006-10-07 7:53]

Hello Claude,
Excellent photo. Very good distributions of geometry forms.
Great work.

Regards,
Idálio

•  
• shutterbill (1734)
• [2006-10-09 18:55]

Hi Claude,
Beautiful symmetry in this shot, nice low POV and excellent B&W work with the tones - overall a nice sharp image with great DOF.
Thanks,
b.

•  
• harpya (48)
• [2006-10-11 11:59]

Hello Claude,

Beautiful angle, I was able to
to take oath that would be seeing a mirror.
That dilemma to proceed, which curves to turn!
Good use of the b/w.
Congratulations!

Sérgio

•  
• Tintin (1982)
• [2006-10-15 20:26]

Une belle symétrie dans cette photo, Claude. J'aime bien toutes les formes géométriques que nous y retrouvont et le point de vue assez bas qui nous donne plein the lignes. Bravo!

•  
• Lionel (3737)
• [2006-10-18 6:02]

Bonjour.
Une très bonne idée d'image et de titre pour cette photo.
Bravo !

•  
• izler (4059)
• [2006-10-18 9:45]

hi claude
here is successful transportation photo which is "detail working". perspective, choice of black-white, sharpness and details are great
TFS
regards
izler

•  
• vinicio (242)
• [2006-10-18 17:27]

Beautiful question, and also, beautiful geometric composition, well done, good idea and perfect result, compliments.
Ciao
Vinicio

•  
• thor68 (4572)
• [2006-10-21 17:40]

hi claude,yeah, very cool, where do i go next? *g*
terrific symmetrical composition and pov, showing the multiple
ways of the train tracks.
the choice of B&W is perfect, creating a special mood.
well seen & captured, thor.

•  
• iGirl (604)
• [2006-10-24 14:14]

Hi Claude, great b&w here, I like the strong symmetry. The tracks come together almost like a puzzle. I've always wondered how they make sure all the trains get on the right tracks so they won't run into each other. :)

Your cropping is great, keeping the focal point on the tracks without any distractions. Thanks for sharing!

Erin

•  
• rgagnon (2156)
• [2006-10-26 6:54]

bonjour Claude
Symétrie, contraste, anecdote, perspective, ... tout y est. excellente utilisation du NetB et quelle netteté!
j'adore et je la mets dans mon album.
Richard

•  
• John_F_Kennedy (8940)
• [2006-11-06 8:30]

I would not like to be locomotive driver... Gerat b&w composition.
Achim

•  
• cezar62 (7880)
• [2006-11-15 8:58]

Hi Claude!
Great composition,great lines, curves and title.
Regards.
Cezar

•  
• rokoslav (1787)
• [2006-11-16 14:36]

Fantastic picture! Great composition and title.

•  
• Hormon_Manyer (2069)
• [2006-11-23 3:35]

Hi Claude,
Yeah, this is great. Title perfectly represents what the photo is about. I feel myself driving my virtual locomotive in Microsoft Train Simulator and don't have an idea where to go, although I have to choose an exact line. :) Good shot, congrats.

•  
• jpdeloof (4828)
• [2006-12-05 3:24]

bonjour claude, joli jeu de lignes, profondeur de champs profonde, grande netteté.
Nous sommes prêt pour le voyage.
Très beau sujet
jp

•  
• sozer (327)
• [2006-12-06 12:52]

Bonsoir Claude,
Very good photo with perfect simmetrie.
BW tones are very good choice.
Great work
Ali

•  
• jafsc (4614)
• [2006-12-11 10:09]

Formidable Claude!! Ça c'est de l'Art pur! Bravo!! Rien à ajouter...
jas

•  
• paulalex32 (74)
• [2006-12-19 21:51]

This is an aweseome shot! When I first saw it, it looked unreal!

•  
• mousehunter (578)
• [2007-01-24 4:41]

Nice angle , perhaps the focus should be led to the upper part of the scene.

•  
• pisces_t (2451)
• [2007-01-24 5:56]

I love this photo. The lines, curves and geometric patterns is great. Well seen and well taken.

TFS Tracey

•  
• parvulescubio (4)
• [2007-01-25 16:21]

very very good picture,
congratulations Claude for this idea.

Lucian.

•  
• jamfest (4209)
• [2007-01-27 16:06]

Very nice pattern/symmetry shot. Well done in B&W with strong composition.

TFS,
David

•  
• aros (717)
• [2007-01-29 6:02]

Simple and effective. Black and white suits it well. I hope you didn't put yourself in any danger to get this!

•  
• melik (2275)
• [2007-02-02 7:14]

Claude, it's a perfect example of symmetrie, b&w and exposure. Well done. Ömer

•  
• amitbiz (1496)
• [2007-02-07 7:56]

Hi Claude,
Lovely shot and little scary too..if 4-5 trains come then..!!!
Amit

•  
• deud (893)
• [2007-02-14 7:30]

this version in b&w is more powerfull, than your color shot "train". very well done. tfs

•  
• Nikofan (270)
• [2007-02-17 20:13]

bah!
L'essentiel est...de ne pas quitter les rails!
Ca mène, toujours, quelque part!
Superbe compo géométrique, belle netteté!
Miam!

Bernard

•  
• Shoot_Score (0)
• [2007-02-17 21:40]

101 is a nice binary number that represents...(?)

No dilemma to those who read boolean!

Whata great switching yard!
Any real engineer would be happy to sail thru here!


Great compo! Great theme!. Good choice to go B&W. Tfs, J.

•  
• bemawu (1539)
• [2007-02-27 17:51]

Bonjour Claude, very good composition with perfect technical handling/

•  
• kasra_arya (163)
• [2007-02-27 18:08]

amazing it catch my eyes

•  
• pat_dub (263)
• [2007-03-03 11:23]

très belle prise, bravo!

•  
• tet (3467)
• [2007-03-09 16:20]

very nice pov! love this claude!

tfs!

•  
• gabbypal (4357)
• [2007-03-13 12:13]

I join the admirers of this shot, Claude.
Great choice of viewpoint and marvellous symmetry. And in Bern even, one of my favorite
towns!.... Merci, Janos

•  
• salil (2076)
• [2007-03-13 14:00]

Brilliant. Almost philosophic. Superb point of view and composition.
Salil

•  
• noborders (720)
• [2007-03-18 15:27]

Je viens de découvrir cette photo, c'est un peu tard, mai je vais l'ajouter à mes favoris...

J'aime beaucoup ton sens de la géométrie, bravo !
Cath.

•  
• cepekdonk (1381)
• [2007-03-21 12:34]

a very interesting picture and a good choice to make it in bw ! i hope the train drivers dont get lost

daniel

•  
• albyro (2483)
• [2007-04-02 10:38]

Beautiful shot.. I love railway.. Bravo!

•  
• gnada (14713)
• [2007-05-07 11:37]

Hi Claude...
Nice B&W shot.
Your pictures are most original i have seen...
George

•  
• cycle (972)
• [2007-05-08 8:40]

Excellent work and perpective.
Good B/W colur, composition, light...
Congrats

•  
• smena (1006)
• [2007-06-29 13:37]

to my fav. ty

•  
• touristdidi (6381)
• [2007-07-13 14:30]

The person in charge, better get it right every time! What a puzzle to us! Has an arty lookj to it!

•  
• eMBeer (1270)
• [2007-08-29 1:14]

Hi Claude,

rails seem to be easy subject, but after I have seen many photos I changed my mind. Yours is good example of few succesfull shots - first glance tells "it's a collage, of the photo and it's reflection". Careful watching reveals that you have chosen perfectly POV to suggest the symmetry, but it's regular photo. I like the acute angle you have used, shortening the perspective, thus "collapsing" the rails to create the nice, geometrical patterns. Wise choice of b&w focusing attention on shapes and composition instead of colurs which hwere are unimportant. tfs

Marek

•  
• Giorgimer (2201)
• [2007-08-29 1:23]

Hi Claude,

not easy to create a artwork from a subject like this. Very good idea, excellent result!
Nice title choice.

Compliments!!

Gio

•  
• bucanas (11549)
• [2007-09-07 17:58]

Hi Claude,
Fantastic photo.
Congratulation.
Ralf

•  
• Jonas_Schmitt_ (340)
• [2007-09-11 10:37]

Hi Claude!
Crazy and very creative picture!I like the depth here and the very good point of view.
Tfs,Jonas

•  
• crisgotiny (2416)
• [2007-09-25 5:37]

wow what a nice railway track, very unique composition very symmetrical. Very neat shot no obstruction but only railway track.I really admire this shot.

tfs
cris(",)

•  
• masuria (450)
• [2007-10-15 1:49]

NICE PHOTO AND ALSO GOOD ENGINEERING,

THANKS FOR SHARING,
YOGESH

•  
• eyesthetix (7895)
• [2007-10-27 13:56]

Hi Claude,
simply brilliant. Use of B&W adds some interest. Very sharp and clear tones.

Best regards, Daniel

•  
• marcin_gutowski (203)
• [2007-10-31 7:14]

Hi Claude,

what can I say... Perfectly cropped, ideal symmetry, fitted B&W, and last but not least, great idea. My biggest and most enthusiastic congratulations. TFS,

Marcin.

•  
• wittmann (865)
• [2007-11-19 0:24]

Hi Claude
Very interested foto, extra B/W.
Regards
Tomek

•  
• pablominto (27446)
• [2007-11-26 5:52]

Hello Claude,
This is well seen!
The composition is cleverly done and close to symmetrical, the frame is full of amazing lines...
Excellent tonality in the black and white conversion, sharp fine details!
Greetings,
Pablo -

PS!
Great to see such a highly rated B&W in TrekLens!

•  
• lopa (8915)
• [2007-11-30 1:44]

Hi Claude,
Excellent geometrycal composition. Wonderful black and white . Good perpective too.
TFS
Lopa

•  
• xodroolis (563)
• [2008-04-14 6:09]

Hello Claude!
GREAT Photo!
Makes me dizzy while looking at it.
Very symmetric capture.
I also like the B&W choice of yours.
Well done!
Nickos

•  
• cbcs (556)
• [2008-06-08 23:33]

Wow! Amazing patterns, I am glad I am not responsible for how it all works! TFS!