House With a View

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• pvangeenen (22)
• [2005-04-14 8:13]

Good Photo and composition, of indeed a typical day.

Thanks for posting.
Pierre.

•  
• tinman (1622)
• [2005-04-14 8:25]
• [+]

Lovely shot - TFS. Has so much charactor in it. Tim

•  
• reddevil (0)
• [2005-04-14 8:28]
• [+]

This is a great picture Pierre, it's so typical Scotland. Well done!!!

Jos

•  
• cloverstar (0)
• [2005-04-14 8:38]

Very pleasant view. I like the mist. Good job on the desaturation. Well done.

•  
• mwebr (3402)
• [2005-04-14 9:55]
• [+]

What a freakin great view. Better yet what a great photo. Nice job with the pp work to help with the background and to bring out the foreground better. If I lived in this home, I would never tire of this scenery.....I would get tired of the cold however. Florida tends to thin the blood after sometime. Great work Pierre.

Michael

•  
• Cfan (235)
• [2005-04-14 10:15]

Awesome view. A very good picture.

•  
• SandPiper (7392)
• [2005-04-14 10:33]
• [+]

A charming house and a glorious view! Beautiful composition......:O)

•  
• Soundsangels (11691)
• [2005-04-14 12:14]
• [+]

Il y a de ces gens qui savent tirer l'épingle du jeu......
Superbe place...rendue de facon tres "à son avantage". Le cadrage et la composition sont parfaits.
Beaucoup de caractère...
Tres bonne idée d'avoir partagé.
Claude

•  
• marthival (243)
• [2005-04-14 14:05]

Très belle photo Pierre. J'aime beaucoup la composition. Quel endroit de rêve, l'Écosse est vraiment particulier et impressionant. Bravo.

•  
• Werewolf (26142)
• [2005-04-14 17:54]
• [+]

Le genre d'endrois où j'aimerais bien me retrouvé quand il fait près de 40 degrées avec Humidex... Prisonier de la nature... Loin de toute liberté électronique! Quitter temporairement cette cage dorée qu'est la civilisation :o)

Bravo! Beau coin de rêve!

•  
• chiaraluna (2560)
• [2005-04-14 19:07]
• [+]

beautiful Pierre! i've often dreamed of having a little house on a Loch in Scotland like this.. and those typically misty days are so wonderful! lovely composition and depth of field and so peaceful.. excellent :-)

Ayda

•  
• erdna (5425)
• [2005-04-14 19:47]

You have a very good picture here with good composition, sharpness and point of view. Adding highlights on the foreground where the house is will improve it.

Andre'

•  
• silver (0)
• [2005-04-14 22:57]
• [+]

Mind posting the original as well? I am curious how it came out from the camera.. I love how you finished it up though.. Very nice!

•  
• chefcop (4638)
• [2005-04-15 4:33]
• [+]

You have done a marvellous job Pierre, this is a beautiful part of the world and you have captured it well. Your pp work has produce an awesome picture that really show off the magnificence of the Scottish landscape. Well done.

Peter

•  
• manny (11941)
• [2005-04-15 5:01]

Postcard perfect. I like the simple and clean composition.

•  
• gaby (1403)
• [2005-04-15 12:47]
• [+]

Pierre,
cette photo est vraiment superbe aussi bien dans sa composition que dans sa tonalité -
Bravo
Merci
Gaby

•  
• jkneze2 (136)
• [2005-04-15 15:26]

Deffinitly a great (PO)view and framing.
Good job.

•  
• sarju (492)
• [2005-04-15 18:23]
• [+]

Well I had seen some house pictures by the lake before ... but never really got an urge to stay in any one of them ... but the house in your picture is very compelling
very nice shot Pierre
well I really don't have the words to let you know how much this picture appealed to me ... and yet I don't know what is it that is appealing ... I guess it is the simplicity of the house ... the quietness of the lake
neways i will leave you herer
ciao
sarju

•  
• Gudule (537)
• [2005-04-15 21:42]
• [+]

Salut Pierre, te voilà de retour. Bon voyage? Et tu nous reviens avec deux excellentes photos. Celle de tes colonnes transposée en N&B fait tout un effet. Des masses d'Une solidité extraordinaire.
Et celle-ci, toute différente...la paix...dans la solitude des fois nécessaire. Le contraste de la maison si bien assise dans ce décor tout à fait écossais est impressionnant.

•  
• TheZubial (3723)
• [2005-04-16 5:03]
• [+]

Beau paysage Professeur
Je crois que les pontagnes sont un peu écrasées par le cadrage. Trop de ciel nuit, mais ici je pense qu'il en manque un rien (c'est mon opinion, je me trompe peut-être)
Il n'empêche que c'est un très beau cliché
bravo Pierre

•  
• cleopatra (1152)
• [2005-04-16 7:14]

Excellent travail de PP Pierre. Tu as su mettre en valeur appropriée tous les détails de cette composition. L'endroit semble en être un de rêve.

Félicitations!

•  
• DavidJenkins (0)
• [2005-04-16 16:10]

Quite the view! This is wonderful scenery and the house adds a nice human dimension to it.

•  
• DAM (1110)
• [2005-04-18 4:31]

Indeed...what a view they have. Scotland looks so much like some our lands here in Canada. Nice colours my friend.
Thanks
DAM

•  
• hojper (4087)
• [2005-04-18 16:23]
• [+]

I see this photo is on its way to the 50 point mark where it definitely belongs. And I guess it is because it is such a dream place more than anything else. Of course you did a great PP job, and the general composition is fine, but what sets it apart is the dream-like quality of the place. That is how we appeal to others - by showing them their dreams.

•  
• Lawman1965 (82)
• [2005-04-24 15:00]

Good work with this image. Great composition.

Rich

•  
• puffy (16617)
• [2005-05-25 15:47]
• [+]

Excellent shot Pierre, I don't know why... this shot give me so much mix feeling, peaceful, sad, lonely and happy in the same time. I can't explain it, and I feel like to have a coffee now... (weird me) I like the composition, infact, everything about this shot I like it. Great stuff! TFS

•  
• danbachmann (555)
• [2005-05-26 13:45]
• - [workshop] [compare] [+]

I like your image here and I think your later cropping was very good. You do have a lot of good details that are just barely there that I think you could bring out. I'll do a workshop to show you.

•  
• ben-u-ron (4051)
• [2005-06-14 16:36]

What a peaceful foto!
Excelent!

Cheers,

Carla

•  
• smeagol (87)
• [2005-11-14 13:00]

Superbe composition, jolie maison (abandonnée?) et quel endroit! J'aimerais bien y être en ce moment. Merci d'avoir partagé. Eric

•  
• spike1 (4321)
• [2005-12-20 9:51]

This is a really beautiful photo Pierre - the setting seems so peaceful. I like the compositon very much, and the greens in the foreground look great against the greys and other pale colours.