Winter Tree

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• tojav (874)
• [2009-02-05 7:51]

Hi Anne,
Interesting formulation of subject. Tree and dark clouds create tune. I congratulate.
Wiesiek

•  
• jean11-3 (4623)
• [2009-02-05 9:20]

A really striking shot Anne.
I like the diagonal line of the fence.
The trees' silhouette is very clear against that cold looking sky.
Tfs, regards Jean.

•  
• WhiteKnight (7570)
• [2009-02-10 4:49]

Nice view, and the tree makes a great silhouette.. Maybe a slight sharpening would be good?

•  
• otherpete (923)
• [2009-05-23 2:16]
• [+]

I love these snow scenes, as you know Anne we don't get them here. The silhouette works well against the white background.

•  
• Sharpshooter (6920)
• [2009-06-25 15:54]

Hi Anne,
Awesome silhouetted tree you've captured here, wouldn't look the same without the gloomy sky in the background. Simple and effective - I like it :).

TFS,
Scott.

•  
• coasties (5654)
• [2009-06-29 13:29]
• [+]

Hi Anne

This is a super shot taken in difficult light, but feel that with a bit of a 'tweak' it would have better visual impact. I find my eye initially goes to the right side of the image where there is a gap between the last fence post and the edge of the image. As the tree branch hangs above the fence post I would suggest cropping the image almost back to the post. The overall image is a bit dull so some work on shadows/highlights, levels and contrast would really enhance this. Then add a wee bit of sharpening and the end result would give this beautiful scene a bit more punch. I have uploaded a workshop to show what I mean.

With all the above said, this is a lovely winter scene and I like the way you have composed the left side allowing the hill to fall off to the flatter area below.The eye follows the journey nicely.


Cheers

Pam

•  
• alper2702 (2492)
• [2009-08-30 13:56]

Hi Anne!
interesting silhouette...well captured with pleasant colors in the background
Alper