At the water's edge

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• Tomek (16862)
• [2009-11-06 15:27]

Hi Sunil:)
Pickering.... there where some nice spots between Toronto and Kingston - some time I would like to go down the lake in Scarborough, nice lime stone formations are present close to boat marina.
OK now about your picture: - entirely is very good but that what is just stunning for me? - COMPOSITION!!!
- just brilliant way done here - I love how you frame this image, really great job, congrats.
Wish you great evening - Tom:)

•  
• bri (2515)
• [2009-11-06 16:32]

Hi Sunil,
Great composition and natural looking colours, excellent DoF. TFS
Bri

•  
• WhiteKnight (7874)
• [2009-11-06 17:26]
• [+]

Very nice Sunil - good composition and light. I think the grad filter PP works well.

I would have cloned out the tiny speck of boat in the distance - other than that a good shot.

DAVid

•  
• dilshan74 (2433)
• [2009-11-06 17:32]

Beautiful POV and composition here of this scene with a wonderful title that really matches the story of this picture. Great use of DOf, wonderful colour/exposure and sharpness achieved. Well done and TFS!

regards,

Dilshan

•  
• Teresat (8823)
• [2009-11-06 18:03]

Boa noite Sunil
A very good composition.
My regards
Teresat

•  
• tjutjut (15954)
• [2009-11-06 19:15]

Hi Sunil,

You have such a great observation and presented in this beautiful image . . a lovely kind of posetcard . . Beautiful photo.

Tfs,
TJutjut

•  
• ShellyOB (2831)
• [2009-11-06 20:23]

Wow, Sunil,
you got some GREAT sharpness and detail at that large an aperture. I love all those darkish subdued colors and the graphism of the posts and the way they curve. Excellent composition and lovely contrast. Wonderfully moody shot and a good eye to see it. Nice work! Many thanks and kind regards,
Shelly

•  
• Royaldevon (16592)
• [2009-11-07 0:49]

Hello Sunil,

Your sensitivity to composition is excellent!
The focus is sharp and you have captured wonderful textural details in the f/g.
I don't agree with David about cloning out the boat. To me, it provides the focal image to take the viewer from the f/g to the b/g.

Kind regards,
Bev :-)

•  
• fransx (9015)
• [2009-11-07 1:40]

Hi Sunil,
A great composition with the ruins of this wooden pier!
Beautiful texture in the wet old wood!
Nice subdued lighting and sharpness.
An excellent control in exposure of such a difficult situation!
A super crop!
Well done,
Regards,

Francis Xavier

•  
• chrisJ (42784)
• [2009-11-08 1:28]

Hi Sunil

I like the repetition of the verticals, & the elongated 'c' shaped curve, of the row of poles & shoreline. The minimalist colour would lend itself well to a b&w conversion. Excellent sharpness & framing. Well done!

•  
• subs (2080)
• [2009-11-09 6:10]
• [+]

Hi Sunil,
You must be getting ready for your trip to SL. Its being raining for days here. But the weather should clear up by the time you get here. I like the tiered effect the stumps have. The overcast skies seem to go well with the antiquity of the pier.
Rgds,
Subashini

•  
• mayurb (105)
• [2009-11-10 0:23]

hi Sunil,
this is great. good pov and beautiful composition. loved the sharpness, the texture, the natural colours..interesting use of gradient. tfs, take care.

regards,
Mayur

•  
• kbeall (3580)
• [2009-11-12 5:32]

Hi Sunil,
Good eye--there's immediate interest here with the curve of the pilings in your frame superimposed on the constant horizon.
All the best,
Karen

•  
• EOSF1 (20613)
• [2009-12-01 4:27]

Hello Sunil, very well composed scene, great atmosphere. Very good exposition, well done my friend.

Mario

•      
• tribord (362)
• [2009-12-02 23:26]

Bonjour Sunil,

This particular photo has a very strong impact.
I like the contrast between the different elements (wood, water and sky).
Certainly one of the shots I like best from your gallery.
everything is well balanced.
Good work.


Damien.