Soba-Udon

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• delnaja (0)
• [2005-11-20 7:45]

Bonjour Marc,
j'aime bien la photo, sa composition, l'instant de vie présenté mais j'avoue que je préfère la version couleur, elle me semble peut-être plus représentative de l'Asie IMHO...
Merci pour le partage
FRed

•  
• tropicalrips (0)
• [2005-11-20 8:35]

very nice b/w Marc :) the tones look good
good street photo, i like this better then the color version :)

•  
• Attila (0)
• [2005-11-20 8:45]

Sometimes you have to break the rules. I find this shot very interesting. I think the sepia works well, not just because of the fact that the colors are too busy on the original, but also because the lights are interesting enough to make the sepia nice. There is a lot of sdetail, and the shot shows a lot of human activity without actually focusing on any one human being. I think it is intriguing that we see no faces, but everyone seems to be doing what they want to be doing. I like this shot.

•  
• ballyna (1914)
• [2005-11-20 9:35]
• - [workshop] [compare] [+]

marc,
a nice compo,very well defining the street life there.there seemed some tilt and shift troubles in this compo to me and I tried small ws ,hope u don't mind.
regards

•  
• frappa76 (1346)
• [2005-11-20 10:39]

mmm...hungry! This version is the one i prefer.Good compo,good choice of colours.I like the movement on the main street.Really good! Francesco

•  
• wishnugaruda (14740)
• [2005-11-20 12:39]

Hi Marc,
I like this shot, it's always interesting to see people and places of other parts of the world. Just looking, how they are living, often so different from my life, but that's what I like to see. So thanks for this impressing shot. B/W image is very good here.
Bye
Sabine - wishnugaruda

•  
• Savignole (4135)
• [2005-11-21 6:47]

Les règles sont faites pour être transgressées... parfois :) Ici, c'est plutôt bien vu. Et si Frédéric a raison sur le fait que la version couleur est plus proche de la réalité asiatique, j'ai quand même tendance à préférer la version NB de ta composition.
Merci à toi,
Martine

•  
• pattyjy (1130)
• [2005-11-21 17:05]

Salut Marc,
Je trouve toujours un peu dommage de faire des photos noir et blanc en Asie alors que les couleurs y sont tellement éclatantes, mais je dois dire que le noir et blanc convient parfaitement à celle-ci. J'aime beaucoup les trois zones de lumière qui donnent toute la profondeur à ton cliché. Bravo. Amitié, Patty.

•  
• supervesna (7)
• [2006-02-16 11:56]

I like the separation between the shop and the people on the street in the background. It's a shame that you can't see the men acually eating the soba or udon (holding the bowl, or something like that). The choice of sepia makes the neon light stand out more. Very nice.

•  
• OeilMagique (20)
• [2006-03-01 23:50]

Merci pour le partage de tes photos. Bon choix du sépia pour la présentation.
Paul